The volunteer programme ‘Night Ravens’: a difference-in-difference analysis of the effects on crime rates

Abstract

The volunteer programme 'Night Ravens' (NR) was founded in Sweden in 1987 and has, over the years, developed into a Scandinavian concept covering large areas of Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Greenland and the Faroe Islands. The NR programme is a crime prevention initiative with adults walking the streets at night in identifiable 'uniforms' in areas with high activity. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effects of the NR programme in Denmark based on a volunteer set-up with a less intrusive approach to situational crime prevention than, for instance, hot spot policing. The analyses are based on a longitudinal data set containing socio-demographic information on all 585 postcode districts in Denmark and quarterly records of six different categories of reported crimes in the years 2001-2010.We apply a differencein-difference design and compare development in crime rates in districts with NR organizations to districts without NR organizations. The results show no difference in the crime rates between Danish postcode districts with and without the NR programme. Hence, we cannot identify positive effects of situational crime prevention when evaluating this Scandinavian volunteer programme with a more informal guardianship.

The effects of the Summer All Out Foot Patrol Initiative in New York City: a difference-in-differences approach

“…It is also not uncommon to find DiD evaluations report lead effects more than three periods before program/policy adoption (Azoulay et al 2019;Venkataramani et al 2019). In other settings, anticipatory effects are largely ignored and the authors only incorporate a static intervention dummy (Braga et al 2018;Larsen et al 2015). 24 The classic DiD framework with two groups and a standardized time index for post-treatment months could only be estimated separately by year.…”

“…We also explored heterogeneous treatment effects by exploiting the timing of deployments (Green et al 2014;Larsen et al 2015). Not only was the SAO initiative a uniformed saturation of public space, but it also exhibited a temporal concentration on weekends and evenings.…”

Recuperación del espacio público para la reducción de la percepción de inseguridad: el caso del fraccionamiento Los Héroes en Puebla, México

“…El grupo Cohesión Comunitaria (2010), Dammert (2003), y Larsen, B. Ø., Kleif, H. B., & Kolodziejczyk, C. (2015), proponen la participación ciudadana en la apropiación de los espacios públicos para contrarrestar a la delincuencia y la violencia. Para ello, Duhau y Giglia (2008) consideran que "no necesariamente se debe suponer la existencia de "identidades colectivas" o de "comunidades locales, pero si una cierta dosis de arraigo, que definimos como el estar vinculado a un lugar mediante la inserción del sujeto en redes de relaciones relativamente densas, situadas en el espacio local" (p.24).…”