The value conflict between freedom and security: Explaining the variation of COVID-19 policies in democracies and autocracies

Abstract

In the name of health security, individual freedoms were constrained in an unprecedented way in many countries, democratic or authoritarian, all over the world during the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet the constraints have not been consistent across countries, which motivates this paper to examine the relevance of value preferences towards freedom or security in the society for COVID-19 policies. Based on data for 40 democratic and authoritarian countries, the analyses show that the variation in the stringency of COVID-19 policies can be explained by value preferences of the population only in autocracies. In democracies, however, we do not find such a relationship. Governments in democratic political systems, we argue, are responsive to their constitutions and face prosecution by the judiciary if they violate the law or provisions of the constitution, limiting their capacity to implement strong COVID-19 policies. Nevertheless, their COVID-19 policies restricted citizens’ freedoms and liberties, which means that these policies were rather not responsive to citizens’ preferences for freedom, democratic rights and liberties. By highlighting how autocracies respond to their citizens’ value preferences for security, this paper contributes to a better understanding of how autocracies might gain legitimacy in times of crises.

Improving the response to future pandemics requires an improved understanding of the role played by institutions, politics, organization, and governance

“…The influence of political factors has also been identified as a driver of pandemic responses. Researchers have assessed how the pandemic response differed between centralized and decentralized political systems [6], as well as between more democratic and more authoritarian systems [7]. Political partisanship has also been identified as a driver of pandemic responses at the level of both governments and individuals.…”