The Validity of Survey Responses on Abortion: Evidence from Estonia

Abstract

This paper presents results of a validation survey of abortion conducted in Tallinn, Estonia in April and May 1992. The sample was drawn from patient records in a maternity hospital. Women who had an abortion in that hospital in 1991 were asked about recent abortions as part of a survey about women's health. More than 80% of the respondents reported having a recent abortion. Some respondents misreported their abortion as a miscarriage. Moreover, some variation in reporting was associated with respondents' characteristics. Ethnic Estonians were less likely to report their abortion than were Russians, women over age 40 were less likely to report the abortion than younger women, and women who had the abortion late in the first trimester were less likely to report that abortion. There was some evidence that unmarried women were less likely than married women to report their abortion, and that women who had borne three or more children were less likely to report their abortion than women who had borne fewer children. These differences probably stem from the extent to which pregnancy or abortion is considered stigmatizing for women in different situations.

Incomplete pregnancy and risk of ovarian cancer: results from two Australian case–control studies and systematic review

“…It is possible that women may have under-reported their experiences due to social stigma or legality issues [54][55][56]. Such under-reporting would not differ between cases and controls [57], though some have suggested otherwise if cases were more prepared to report such details if perceived as contributing to their disease [58].…”

Induced Abortion in Thailand: Current Situation in Public Hospitals and Legal Perspectives

“…10,11 A public hospital-based approach in Thailand largely captures legal abortions for medical indications and those for women with complications who need hospital care. Access to care depends on fear of sanctions, geographic and financial accessibility, and social and health worker attitudes.…”

Unsafe abortion in 2008: global and regional levels and trends

“…However, surveys show that substantial under-reporting occurs even where abortion is both accessible and available within the legal framework. [16][17][18][19] It appears that early pregnancy terminations and events occurring some time back in the past are less frequently reported. 20 When abortions are clandestine, women tend to under-report induced abortions in surveys despite assurance of confidentiality, and because of the stigma attached to the event, or may only admit to a spontaneous abortion (miscarriage).…”