The use of player tracking data to analyze defensive play in professional soccer - A scoping review

Abstract

The analysis of tracking data in tactical game analysis is a topic of rising interest, as more detailed insights into performance structure in soccer can be obtained compared to traditional (e.g. notational) analyzes. Compared to the variety and detailed analyzes of offensive play, the number of studies analyzing the defensive play is low. However, in recent years, an increasing number of studies investigating defensive play have been published, so it seems useful to provide an overview of the current state of research in this area. Therefore, this study aims to identify the approaches that have been used to analyze the defensive play in professional soccer using player tracking data and to reveal the findings on successful defensive play. A systematic literature search of electronic databases (PubMed ( n = 604), Web of Science ( n = 593), and SPORTDiscuss ( n = 872)) was conducted according to the PRISMA extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR). Studies that were included used tracking data of professional adult male soccer and analyzed defensive play. The result is a total of 23 studies that were analyzed in detail using the standardized quality assessment checklist for systematic reviews in sports science. The synthesis of results was carried out descriptively by organizing the results into different levels of tactical play (individual level, group level, team level). All included studies were of good methodological quality. The approaches to investigate defensive play using tracking data are highly heterogeneous (e.g. analysis of defensive pressure, analysis of synchronization, behavioral analyzes, ball recoveries). Successful defensive play is characterized by high pressure at the individual level, by high inter-team and intra-team synchronization and balanced defense at the group level, and by a compact coordinated organization at the team level. By summarizing the state of research on defensive play in soccer using sophisticated analysis approaches that showcase the possibilities of tracking data, this study provides an important foundation for future research in this area.

The influence of tactical formation on physical and technical match performance in male soccer: A systematic review

“…Another investigation revealed that midfielders (central, wide, or offensive) play more passes in a 4-4-2 formation, than midfielders in a 4-2-3-1 formation. 21 Previous reviews have already looked at the match performance of soccer players from a variety of perspectives 11,[22][23][24][25] . However, the current body of literature is characterized by heterogeneous methodological approaches, and an overview that summarizes the way tactical formation affects soccer match performance of a team and a positional level does not exist.…”

How Coaches Can Improve Their Teams’ Match Performance—The Influence of In-Game Changes of Tactical Formation in Professional Soccer

“…Furthermore, since computer technology and science allowed researchers to deal with larger data sets, the construct of the tactical soccer performance received increasing attention ( Sarmento et al, 2018 ). Particularly, current reviews highlight the offensive and defensive tactical performance of single players, groups, and whole teams, thus pointing to the great opportunities in-game analysis research ( Lepschy et al, 2018 ; Goes et al, 2020 ; Forcher et al, 2022a ). Similarly, the interest in the influence of tactical factors on soccer performance has also increased recently ( Modric et al, 2020 ; Vilamitjana et al, 2021 ).…”

Clustering ball possession duration according to players’ role in football small-sided games

“…Considering that the prevalent intention from this playing position is to score goals, they usually seem to focus more on the surrounding information (e.g., space between defenders, distance to the target, goal location) [ 51 ] and engage in more individual situations such 1vs1 to create space [ 20 ]. However, at modern football where there seems to be an emergent trend to defend more compact and with a high number of defenders [ 52 ], which may model the attacker’s role towards deceiving the opponents’ by moving to other areas or holding the ball until receiving pressure to then be able to find a free man. As consequence it may contribute towards longer ball possessions, while shorter ball possessions may be characterized by more individual actions.…”