The use of implicit persuasion in decision-making about treatment for end-stage kidney disease

Abstract

Background: There are various options for managing end-stage kidney disease. Each option impacts the lives of patients differently. When weighing the pros and cons of the different options, patients’ values, needs and preferences should, therefore, be taken into account. However, despite the best intentions, nephrologists may, more or less deliberately, convey a treatment preference and thereby steer the decision-making process. Being aware of such implicit persuasion could help to further optimise shared decision-making (SDM). This study explores verbal acts of implicit persuasion during outpatient consultations scheduled to make a final treatment decision. These consultations mark the end of a multi-consultation, educational process and summarise treatment aspects discussed previously. Methods: Observations of video-recorded outpatient consultations in nephrology ( n = 20) were used to capture different forms of implicit persuasion. To this purpose, a coding scheme was developed. Results: In nearly every consultation nephrologists used some form of implicit persuasion. Frequently observed behaviours included selectively presenting treatment options, benefits and harms, and giving the impression that undergoing or foregoing treatment is unusual. The extent to which nephrologists used these behaviours differed. Conclusion: The use of implicit persuasion while discussing different kidney replacement modalities appears diverse and quite common. Nephrologists should be made aware of these behaviours as implicit persuasion might prevent patients to become knowledgeable in each treatment option, thereby affecting SDM and causing decisional regret. The developed coding scheme for observing implicit persuasion elicits useful and clinically relevant examples which could be used when providing feedback to nephrologists.

Choosing conservative care in advanced chronic kidney disease: a scoping review of patients’ perspectives

“…Healthcare professionals might steer decision-making unintentionally due to their own preference about which treatment suits the patient best. Previous research showed that implicit persuasion is common in the process of choosing a treatment modality [ 42 ]. Additionally, patient decision making might be driven by fear of death or might be further complicated due to cognitive impairment and uraemia [ 43 ].…”

Systems Innovations to Increase Home Dialysis Utilization

“…19 Gaps in provider knowledge and expertise may contribute to implicit persuasion to patients with regard to KRT options. 20 Short in-person courses have been offered by Home Dialysis University, a program associated with the International Society for Peritoneal Dialysis. A pilot cohort study completed in 2021 demonstrated that a virtual education program consisting of didactic lectures, assigned literature review, and case discussions significantly improved the comfort of practicing nephrologists with home dialysis.…”

“…19 Gaps in provider knowledge and expertise may contribute to implicit persuasion to patients with regard to KRT options. 20…”

Smoothing transition to dialysis to improve early outcomes after dialysis initiation among old and frail adults—a narrative review

“…Despite the best intentions, it can be challenging for physicians to balance objective clinical assessment, intuition and subjective perception. Thus it was observed that implicit persuasion among physicians is common when discussing different treatment modalities [ 65 ]. Good communication is a healthy blend of empathy, common sense, commitment and time to listen to the patient and relatives.…”