The ubiquity of uncertainty: a scoping review on how undergraduate health professions’ students engage with uncertainty

Abstract

Although the evidence base around uncertainty and education has expanded in recent years, a lack of clarity around conceptual terms and a heterogeneity of study designs means that this landscape remains indistinct. This scoping review explores how undergraduate health professions' students learn to engage with uncertainty related to their academic practice. To our knowledge, this is the first scoping review which examines teaching and learning related to uncertainty across multiple health professions. The scoping review is underpinned by the five-stage framework of (Arksey and O'Malley in Scoping studies: Towards a methodological framework International Journal of Social Research Methodology 8(1) 19-32, 2005). We searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsychINFO, ISI Web of Science, and CINAHL and hand-searched selected health professions’ education journals. The search strategy yielded a total of 5,017 articles, of which 97 were included in the final review. Four major themes were identified: “Learners’ interactions with uncertainty”; “Factors that influence learner experiences”; “Educational outcomes”; and, “Teaching and learning approaches”. Our findings highlight that uncertainty is a ubiquitous concern in health professions’ education, with students experiencing different forms of uncertainty at many stages of their training. These experiences are influenced by both individual and system-related factors. Formal teaching strategies that directly support learning around uncertainty were infrequent, and included arts-based teaching, and clinical case presentations. Students also met with uncertainty indirectly through problem-based learning, clinical teaching, humanities teaching, simulation, team-based learning, small group learning, tactical games, online discussion of anatomy topics, and virtual patients. Reflection and reflective practice are also mentioned as strategies within the literature.

Students' Attitudes Toward Online Music Education During the COVID 19 Lockdown

“…Also, intolerance to uncertainty is involved in several psychological disorders, such as panic disorder, social anxiety, depression, eating disorders, obsessive compulsive disorder (Shihata et al, 2016;McEvoy et al, 2019). Another study concludes that students studying medical, technical and science faculties show a lower level of intolerance of uncertainty than students in humanistic faculties (Moffett et al, 2021).…”

Hope in the uncertainties and certainty for parents of children with rare neurological disorders. Part I (of 3): Uncertainty

“…[26][27][28] Because of this, a capacity to manage uncertainty is now recognised as a core dimension in clinician professional competence, 29 although education about how to manage uncertainty remains rare within clinical training. 29,30 Uncertainties can drive curiosity, knowledge and action to remove some of the doubts or threats. Uncertainty is not always isolating; it motivates peer review and input, collaborations and relationships.…”

Medical Students and the Drive for a Single Right Answer: Teaching Complexity and Uncertainty

“…The second factor influencing students’ desire for answers is discomfort with uncertainty. Uncertainty has been widely recognized as an inevitable and ubiquitous aspect of clinical medicine ( 30 , 31 ), and many have highlighted the important role of medical education for increasing students’ awareness and tolerance of this ambiguity ( 31 – 33 ). Notably, the work of Bhise and colleagues highlights the prevalence of diagnostic uncertainty in the practice of medicine and offers a clearer definition so that it can be better quantified and addressed in clinical decision-making ( 34 ).…”