The True Cost of Food: A Preliminary Assessment

Abstract

Ensuring sustainable food systems requires vastly reducing their environmental and health costs while making healthy and sustainable food affordable to all. One of the central problems of current food systems is that many of the costs of harmful foods are externalized, i.e., are not reflected in market prices. At the same time, the benefits of healthful foods are not appreciated. Due to externalities, sustainable and healthy food is often less affordable to consumers and less profitable for businesses than unsustainable and unhealthy food. Externalities and other market failures lead to unintended consequences for present and future generations, destroying nature and perpetuating social injustices such as underpay for workers, food insecurity, illness, premature death and other harms. We urgently need to address the fundamental causes of these problems. This chapter sets out the results of an analysis to determine the current cost of externalities in food systems and the potential impact of a shift in diets to more healthy and sustainable production and consumption patterns. The current externalities were estimated to be almost double (19.8 trillion USD) the current total global food consumption (9 trillion USD). These externalities accrue from 7 trillion USD (range 4–11) in environmental costs, 11 trillion USD (range 3–39) in costs to human life and 1 trillion USD (range 0.2–1.7) in economic costs. This means that food is roughly a third cheaper than it would be if these externalities were included. More studies are needed to quantify the costs and benefits of food systems that would support a global shift to more sustainable and healthy diets. However, the evidence presented in this chapter points to the urgent need for a system reset to account for these ‘hidden costs’ in food systems and calls for bold actions to redefine the incentives for producing and consuming healthier and more sustainable diets. The first step to correct for these ‘hidden costs’ is to redefine the value of food through true-cost accounting (TCA) so as to address externalities and other market failures. TCA reveals the true value of food by making the benefits of affordable and healthy food visible and revealing the costs of damage to the environment and human health 3.

Food Is Medicine: A Presidential Advisory From the American Heart Association

“…23 Higher health and environmental costs of staple foods are not fully factored into food prices, making foods with these external costs less expensive than their true costs. 24 There are, in essence, a set of factors that mean people often have to “swim upstream” in their efforts to be healthy.…”

Multiple meanings of “equitable food systems”: food systems and discursive politics of change

“…The issue here is that wealth is often derived from the exploitation of people and environments (Holt-Giménez, 2019;Patel and Moore, 2020). This is so, as capitalism is premised on prioritizing market and private sector interests and does not account for environmental, social, health, and economic externalities (Hendriks et al, 2023) associated with such promotion (Holt-Giménez, 2019;Patel and Moore, 2020;Chandrasekaran et al, 2021). Indigenous peoples, women, and classed and racialized workers, while not exclusive categories, most often reap the burdens of inherently exploitative food systems, as, according to this perspective, capitalism functions through systems of patriarchy and imperialism (Patel and Moore, 2020).…”

Green Public Procurement as a Tool for Sustainable and Secure Food Policy: Evidence from Poland

“…One of the main obstacles of their use are the implementation and maintenance costs (Vermeir et al, 2020;EUPH, 2017;Hendriks et al, 2021), the low uptake of tools to stimulate sustainable consumption (Dawkins et al, 2019), as well as potential public resistance to stronger actions and measures to limit the freedom of consumers' buying and retailers' selling behavior (Jürkenbeck et al, 2020).…”