1992
DOI: 10.1515/9780691217758
|View full text |Cite
|
Sign up to set email alerts
|

The Textual Condition

Help me understand this report

Search citation statements

Order By: Relevance

Paper Sections

Select...
1
1
1
1

Citation Types

0
12
0

Year Published

2002
2002
2024
2024

Publication Types

Select...
6
1

Relationship

0
7

Authors

Journals

citations
Cited by 118 publications
(12 citation statements)
references
References 0 publications
0
12
0
Order By: Relevance
“…Gesturing to 'a storm of scholarly dispute' after the appearance of The Poems: a New Edition (1983), McGann devoted a couple of pages of The Textual Condition (1991) to the 'notorious case of Yeats' as an example to 'indicate how and why to concept "author's (final) intentions)" cannot be used to determine copytext', concluding 'Suffice it to say that no one editing Yeats, given the state of the archive as it is presently known, could use "author's (final) intentions" as the determinative criterion for deciding on copy-text for many, perhaps most, of the poems, and especially the so-called Last Poems', says McGann, warily gesturing to Richard Finneran's accompanying volume, Editing Yeats's Poems. 95 'Final intention'-rightly in my view-had been Finneran's criterion in his choice of principal copy-text, even if-disastrouslyhe had failed to see that the Collected Poems was a stop-gap, a 'radial development' (to use McGann's term 96 ) of Yeats's larger publishing programme during the Depression. Mrs Yeats and Thomas Mark had left plenty of evidence that the decision to end the Last Poems volume-unit with 'Under Ben Bulben' was her decision on his suggestion, despite Yeats's placement of the poem at the beginning of Last Poems and Two Plays.…”
Section: G Thomas Tanselle Widens This Pragmatismmentioning
confidence: 97%
See 3 more Smart Citations
“…Gesturing to 'a storm of scholarly dispute' after the appearance of The Poems: a New Edition (1983), McGann devoted a couple of pages of The Textual Condition (1991) to the 'notorious case of Yeats' as an example to 'indicate how and why to concept "author's (final) intentions)" cannot be used to determine copytext', concluding 'Suffice it to say that no one editing Yeats, given the state of the archive as it is presently known, could use "author's (final) intentions" as the determinative criterion for deciding on copy-text for many, perhaps most, of the poems, and especially the so-called Last Poems', says McGann, warily gesturing to Richard Finneran's accompanying volume, Editing Yeats's Poems. 95 'Final intention'-rightly in my view-had been Finneran's criterion in his choice of principal copy-text, even if-disastrouslyhe had failed to see that the Collected Poems was a stop-gap, a 'radial development' (to use McGann's term 96 ) of Yeats's larger publishing programme during the Depression. Mrs Yeats and Thomas Mark had left plenty of evidence that the decision to end the Last Poems volume-unit with 'Under Ben Bulben' was her decision on his suggestion, despite Yeats's placement of the poem at the beginning of Last Poems and Two Plays.…”
Section: G Thomas Tanselle Widens This Pragmatismmentioning
confidence: 97%
“…98 Lady Gregory, however, thought that the printers (and Lennox Robinson's previous failed outlet, the Nation) had objected not to his beliefs but to 'his way of supporting it', and told George Yeats that it would be hardly necessary to display the immortality of the soul. She, though she didn't support me when I told him so-is sorry Willie is writing 95 On the embedded quotations from Yeats's work, see above 165-66, nn. 91 for them, says everyone will recognise the manifesto as his though he doesn't believe they will, and that he has given them his Leda poem and a fine thing among his other poems in [The Cat and the Moon 1924] but is, now it is known it goes into Tomorrow, being spoken of as something horribly indecent.…”
Section: The To-morrow Falloutmentioning
confidence: 99%
See 2 more Smart Citations
“…94 92 Cf., Yeats's lines from ' This passage is best read as an act of homage to Yeats's table talk, to his poems, to the yet-to-be published A Vision (1925), to the Blake he regularly quoted ('The Holy Spirit is an intellectual fountain'), to his denunciation of atheist Bishops, and, in that final phrase about 'the imperishable substance of the stars' again to the Blake essays, to 'Father Christian Rosencrux', Rosa Alchemica, and The Unicorn from the Stars. 95 Context in such a journal is mutual reinforcement. In To-Morrow, everything pulled in the direction of rebellion.…”
Section: '[F]umbling In the Greasy Till'mentioning
confidence: 99%