The temporality of humanitarianism : Provincializing everyday volunteer practices at European borders

Abstract

While recognizing that ‘volunteering for refugees’ is entangled in ethical and political power dimensions, this article will discuss how we can ethnographically explore the everyday humanitarian practices of volunteers as shaped in intrinsic ways by their mode of being in the world as ethically concerned human beings. Building on recent scholarship within the anthropology of humanitarianism in which local and everyday versions of humanitarian practice are foregrounded, we wish to further the understanding of everyday volunteer practices through establishing a lens of temporality. Based on ethnographic fieldwork and qualitative interviews among small-scale volunteer networks and NGOs in Greece and in Northern Europe working in response to the refugee influx to Europe since 2015, we suggest three different modalities of volunteering among non-professionals, which we designate: temporality of crisis, which concentrates on the impulse to help as an immediate response to a critical moment in time, temporality of care expressing the asymmetrical presences in the field of volunteering and temporality of reflexivity, which highlights ambivalence and doubt as intrinsic to the volunteer practices. In this article, we aim for a provincializing of everyday humanitarian practices and explore humanitarianism ‘from the ground’ and in specific locations and times.

On the Right Side of History: How Memories of World War Two Nourish Subversive Humanitarianism

“…However, we both respected our informants' rights to silence, privacy, and non-participation. Moreover, recognising how narratives and representations can harm, we have sought to combine criticism with respect and portray our informants as ethically concerned and reflective human beings (Bendixsen & Sandberg 2021). We also highlight the political potential of their actions and contribute to their struggles in different ways through political, academic and social engagements.…”

Vernacular Humanitarianisms

“…All the articles in this special issue discuss relatively recent small-scale experiments in helping fellow humans that cannot be neatly fi tted into any of the usual categories of help, traversing instead the boundaries between humanitarianism, welfare, voluntarism, activism or development. 3 Small-scale experiments in helping seem to have mushroomed over the last several decades (Bendixsen and Sandberg 2021;Cabot 2019;Drotbohm 2015;Ege and Moser 2021;Feischmidt et al 2018;Zhukova 2020). Th ey link a wide range of actors -including state institutions, international agencies, municipal governments, self-managed communities of neighbours, civic associations, grassroots networks of volunteers, private fi rms and so on -who enter into new kinds of assemblages, distributing responsibility for others' survival and well-being in novel and complex ways.…”