The technical efficiency of maternal and child health hospitals in China: a case study of Hubei Province

Abstract

Background Maternal and child health (MCH) hospitals play an essential role in providing MCH services in China, while the supply has become increasingly challenging in the past decade, especially among secondary MCH hospitals. In this study we aimed to evaluate the technical efficiency (TE) of secondary MCH hospitals in Hubei province (China) to generate evidence-based decision-making for efficiency improvement. Methods The data were collected from the Department of Maternal and Child Health of Health Commission of Hubei Province in 2019. A total of 59 out of 74 secondary MCH hospitals were included as our study sample. Four input indicators (number of health professionals, number of beds, number of equipment with value greater than 10,000 RMB Yuan, building area for hospital operations) and three output indicators (number of total diagnostic patients, number of discharged patients, and number of birth deliveries) were selected based on previous literature. TE scores of the sample hospitals were estimated by using Bootstrap-Data Envelopment Analysis (Bootstrap-DEA). Results After bias-correction with Bootstrap-DEA model, the average TE score of the MCH hospitals was 0.673. 20 (33.89%) MCH hospitals had TE scores below the average. No MCH hospitals achieved excellent efficiency; 16 (27.11%) MCH hospitals reached good efficiency; and 26 (44.06%) MCH hospitals fell into poor and failing efficiency. Besides, 17 MCH hospitals had TE scores of 1 before bias-corrections, while none of them reached 1 after bias correction. Conclusions Significant capacity variations existed among the secondary MCH hospitals in terms of input and output indicators and their overall TE was low in Hubei of China. For better improvement, the secondary MCH hospitals in Hubei need to improve their internal management and strengthen the construction of their information systems. A series of policy supports are needed from the health and insurance administrations to optimize health resources. Third-party performance evaluation can be piloted to improve efficiency and overall performance of the MCH hospitals. The policy recommendations we raise for MCH hospitals in Hubei can be worth learning for some low- and middle- income countries.

Measuring Productivity and Relative Efficiency of Public Tertiary Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospitals in Hubei, China

“…Utilization of healthcare resources, performance evaluation, strengthening information systems and internal hospital management can be prioritized to further to enhance technical efficiency. 20 It is worth noting that external factors related to regional healthcare resource disparities in Hubei Province may also contribute to the varying efficiency levels observed. Addressing these external factors and implementing effective internal management strategies will be crucial for improving the overall performance of TCM hospitals.…”

“…According to the classification of bias-corrected TE scores, 5 categories were created, including excellent efficiency [0.9000, 1.0000], good efficiency [0.8000, 0.9000], average efficiency [0.7000, 0.8000], poor efficiency [0.6000, 0.7000], and failing efficiency [0.000, 0.6000]. 18 , 20 Besides, the ranking orders were determined based on the bias-corrected TE scores.…”