The Structural Impediments to Human Service Collaboration: Examining Welfare Reform at the Front Lines

Abstract

This article examines the ability of frontline human service agencies to collaborate across organizational boundaries. Data come from an in-depth study of the public welfare and private welfare-to-work contractors in two Michigan counties and document significant problems that arise from the inability of these two sectors to collaborate in the provision of welfare programs. I use ethnographic methods that capture the perspectives of frontline workers themselves in order to understand how collaboration is actually thwarted. In spite of dramatically different organizational settings, frontline staff in both sectors draw on the same sources of evidence, that is, past relations, daily experiences, and client stories, when assessing the organizations with which they are mandated to collaborate. These collective beliefs create parameters within which staff interpret events and react to them. Their interpretations and reactions further reinforce the beliefs shared throughout the organization about the legitimacy, efficiency, and effectiveness of the partner organization. In this way, the social process at the front lines of the welfare system creates systemic barriers to collaboration. I conclude by considering how this analysis can help the local manager improve policy implementation and human service collaboration. Volumes have been written about the importance of increasing human service coordination, collaboration, and service integration to improve the quality and availability of social services for children and families. 1 Collaborative efforts run the gamut from executive meetings for joint planning of new community initiatives to ''one-stop'' service centers

Policy Evaluation Of Performances Allowance using System Dynamics Approach: Case Study Of Indonesia Navy

“…Some domains of public policy, such as utilities, transport infrastructure, and national security, apply routine logic and technology where raw materials can be viewed, measured, and analyzed and the results are also measured (Hasenfeld 1983). Other policy domains such as social services or economic development often depend on the individual or community attributes that the policy aims, especially when it comes to personnel as the main object and the goal is to change the behavior of individuals through a system (Sandfort 1999). As an academic discipline, public policy integrates other fields of social science such as economics, sociology and management.…”

The Challenges Non-Profit Community Action Agency Leaders Face in Collaborating with Non-Profit Human Services Organizations

“…The focus of collaboration is evident in the fact that governmental funding streams often required of ongoing human service collaboration human service collaboration in order for communities to secure funding (Sandfort, 1999). The idea of collaboration is embraced in the field of human services since policy makers and practitioners realize that on single organization is in the position to successfully address the multifaceted problems that face society (Mayhew, 2012).…”

Measuring Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) Service Providers’ Attitudes: The Development of the Survivor-Defined Advocacy Scale (SDAS)

“…Specifically, service providers' values, attitudes, and perceptions appear to strongly influence whether and how workers implement best practice models (Glisson and James 2002;Hedeker et al 1994). Some service providers in fact disregard models that do not align with their personal worldview (Meyers et al 1998;Sandfort 1999). For example, homelessness service providers are less likely to provide excellent services if the provider personally believes clients are to blame for their current situations and the homeless do not exhibit an attitude of determination (Lindsey 1998).…”