The STEM Requirements of 'Non-STEM' Jobs: Evidence from UK Online Vacancy Postings and Implications for Skills & Knowledge Shortages

Abstract

Do employers in "non-STEM" occupations (e.g. Graphic Designers, Economists) seek to hire STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) graduates with a higher probability than non-STEM ones for knowledge and skills that they have acquired through their STEM education (e.g. "Microsoft C#", "Systems Engineering") and not simply for their problem solving and analytical abilities? This is an important question in the UK where less than half of STEM graduates work in STEM occupations and where this apparent leakage from the "STEM pipeline" is often considered as a wastage of resources. To address it, this paper goes beyond the discrete divide of occupations into STEM vs. non-STEM and measures STEM requirements at the level of jobs by examining the universe of UK online vacancy postings between 2012 and 2016. We design and evaluate machine learning algorithms that classify thousands of keywords collected from job adverts and millions of vacancies into STEM and non-STEM. 35% of all STEM jobs belong to non-STEM occupations and 15% of all postings in non-STEM occupations are STEM. Moreover, STEM jobs are associated with higher wages within both STEM and non-STEM occupations, even after controlling for detailed occupations, education, experience requirements, employers, etc. Although our results indicate that the STEM pipeline breakdown may be less problematic than typically thought, we also find that many of the STEM requirements of "non-STEM" jobs could be acquired with STEM training that is less advanced than a full time STEM education. Hence, a more efficient way of satisfying the STEM demand in non-STEM occupations could be to teach more STEM in non-STEM disciplines. We develop a simple abstract framework to show how this education policy could help reduce STEM shortages in both STEM and non-STEM occupations. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior permission in writing of the publisher nor be issued to the public or circulated in any form other than that in which it is published.Requests for permission to reproduce any article or part of the Working Paper should be sent to the editor at the above address. © Inna Grinis submitted 2017 THE STEM REQUIREMENTS OF "NON-STEM" JOBS: EVIDENCE FROM UK ONLINE VACANCY POSTINGS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR SKILLS & KNOWLEDGE SHORTAGESINNA GRINIS* Abstract. Do employers in "non-STEM" occupations (e.g. Graphic Designers, Economists) seek to hire STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) graduates with a higher probability than non-STEM ones for knowledge and skills that they have acquired through their STEM education (e.g. "Microsoft C#", "Systems Engineering") and not simply for their problem solving and analytical abilities? This is an important question in the UK where less than half of STEM graduates work in STEM occupations and where this apparent leakage from the "STEM pipeline" is often considered as a wastage of resources. To addre...

Demand for AI skills in jobs

“…Dillender, Marcus, Eliza C. Forsythe (2019 [25]) focus on changing skill requirements due to the computerisation of white-collar jobs. Goldfarb, Bledi and Teodoridis (2019 [26]) use BGT data to compare machine learning to other emerging technologies in terms of breadth of industries and research roles as well as the costs of innovation in organisational practices.…”

“…Including information about the frequency with which keywords appear in the same job openings would give information on how intensive jobs may be with respect to that skill(s), and how centred they may be around certain sets of skills. 26 Figure 11 below shows the result of the burst analysis done on pooled data for Canada, the United Kingdom, the United States and Singapore for the period 2012-18, whereas To give an idea of the extent to which the demand for certain skills accelerated at the international level, Figure 12 displays those keywords for which demand burst in more than one country during the period considered and indicate the countries where this happens. The different shades of grey denote the weight of the burst, which can be understood as the intensity of the acceleration in the skills demanded.…”

“…See Dernis, Squicciarini and de Pinho (2015 [32])) for details about the implication of such a choice. 26 We may embark on such an analysis in the future. It may be interesting to note that particularly the keyword "robot" in the US is highly sensitive to the way the frequencies are calculated.…”

Pedagogies for employability: understanding the needs of STEM students through a new approach to employability development

“…In reality, retention and attrition rates are difficult to assess because over one-third of contemporary STEM positions belong to non-STEM occupations and one-sixth of the jobs advertised in non-STEM occupations are in fact STEM roles (Grinis, 2016). The 'growing prevalence of STEM skill requirements across a broader array of jobs and occupations' (Healy, Nicholson, & Gahan, 2017, p. 50) indicates that a pedagogy for employability in STEM should operate beyond discipline silos and prepare students for diverse careers.…”

Transforming 21st-century Leader Competencies by Developing Mindfulness

“…We find it to be a complementary feature not only among prototypical high-skill occupations but also Secretarial and Administrative occupations. Mastery of medium-skill science is already indispensable to a number of paraprofessional positions -from radiology technicians to electricians (Rothwell, 2013;Grinis, 2017).…”