Purpose: Ultra-high dose-rate radiotherapy (FLASH) has been shown to mitigate normal tissue toxicities associated with conventional dose rate radiotherapy (CONV) without compromising tumor killing in preclinical models. A prominent challenge in preclinical radiation research, including FLASH, is validating both the physical dosimetry and the biological effects across multiple institutions. Methods: We previously demonstrated dosimetric reproducibility of two different electron FLASH devices at separate institutions using standardized phantoms and dosimeters. In this study, we compared the outcome of FLASH and CONV 10 Gy whole brain irradiation on female adult mice at both institutions to evaluate the reproducibility and temporal evolution of multiple endpoints. Results: FLASH sparing of behavioral performance on novel object recognition (4 months post-irradiation) and electrophysiologic long-term potentiation (LTP, 5-months post-irradiation) was reproduced between institutions. Interestingly, differences between FLASH and CONV on the endpoints of hippocampal neurogenesis (Sox2, doublecortin), neuroinflammation (microglial activation), and electrophysiology (LTP) at late times were not observed at early times. Conclusions: In summary, we demonstrated reproducible FLASH sparing effects between two beams and two institutions with validated dosimetry. FLASH sparing effects on the endpoints evaluated manifested at late but not early time points.