The Social Structure of Criminalized and Medicalized School Discipline

Abstract

In this article, the author examines how school-and district-level racial/ethnic and socioeconomic compositions influence schools' use of different types of criminalized and medicalized school discipline. Using a large data set containing information on over 60,000 schools in over 6,000 districts, the authors uses multilevel modeling and a group-mean modeling strategy to answer several important questions about school discipline. First, how do school-and district-level racial and ethnic compositions influence criminalized school discipline and medicalization? Second, how do levels of school and district economic disadvantage influence criminalized school discipline and medicalization? Third, how does district-level economic disadvantage moderate the relationship between school racial/ethnic composition and criminalized school discipline and medicalization? The results generally support hypotheses that schools and districts with relatively larger minority and poor populations are more likely to implement criminalized disciplinary policies, including suspensions and expulsion or police referrals or arrests, and less likely to medicalize students through behavioral plans put in place through laws such as Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. However, results from cross-level interaction models suggest that district-level economic disadvantage moderates the influence of school racial composition on criminalized school discipline and medicalization.

Associations between demographic characteristics and physical activity practices in Nevada schools

“…Students in schools with larger shares of Black students face the most disadvantages; they are less likely to receive classroom activity breaks and to have access to bike racks and more likely to have recess/PE withheld for disciplinary reasons. These findings are not surprising given research showing that Black children are more likely than White children to be subjected to punitive control measures in schools (Fenning and Rose, 2007; Horner et al, 2010; Ramey, 2015; Welch and Payne, 2010). Moreover, schools with larger percentages of Black students are less likely to train recess supervisors to promote PA.…”

The Social Construction of Child Social Control via Criminalization and Medicalization: Why Race Matters

“…). Finally, whites attend schools with higher rates of enrollment in behavioral IEPs than blacks and Hispanics children (Hinshaw and Scheffler ; Ramey ).…”

A Different Kind of Discipline: Social Reproduction and the Transmission of Non‐cognitive Skills at an Urban Charter School

“…When students repeatedly distracted other students or threatened physical harm, teachers asked students to “take a break” away from the other students for 30 seconds to several minutes or called on the school's restorative justice coordinator to remove students from class for individual conferencing. These practices appeared to maximize the time that students who exhibited the most significant academic and behavioral challenges were present for instruction, providing an alternative to zero‐tolerance, exclusionary discipline practices adopted by other public schools (Karp and Breslin ; Ramey ).…”