The skills gap in hospital management: a comparative analysis of hospital managers in the public and private sectors in South Africa

Abstract

A lack of management capacity has been identified as the key stumbling block to attaining the goals of health for all in South Africa. As part of the overall management development process, this research aims to identify the skills that are important for health services management and to evaluate managers' self-assessed proficiency in each of these skills. We also examined the impact of past training on perceived competency levels. A cross-sectional survey using a self-administered questionnaire was conducted among 404 hospital managers in the South African public and private sectors. Respondents were asked to rate the level of importance that each proposed competency had in their job and to indicate their proficiency in each skill. Both public and private sector managers rated competencies related to 'people management', 'self-management' and 'task-related skills' highest followed by 'strategic planning' and 'health delivery', respectively. The largest differences between mean importance rating and mean skill rating for public sector managers were for people management skills, task-related skills and self-management skills. The largest deficits for private sector managers were for people management skills, self-management skills and health delivery skills. Informal management development programmes were found to be more valuable in improving management skills. These findings reflect the reality of the local health service environment and the need of health managers. It will be useful in the conceptualization, design and delivery of health management programmes aimed at enhancing current and future management and leadership capacity in the health sector in South Africa.

Perceived health care workforce needs in Lebanon: a step towards informed human resources planning and professional development

“…The findings of this project show consistency with other studies (3,9,26) and with the recommendations of WHO in relation to quality improvement, partnering, and information and communication technology. These competencies have been identified by WHO as basic for effective delivery of care for patients, especially in developing countries (2,11).…”

“…They are context-dependent and should be assessed taking into consideration the critical issues in a health care system and the cultural characteristics of that environment (1,8). It is expected that managers and health professionals combine business practices with clinical and health care knowledge to lead their organizations and contribute to the improvement of their health care system (3,8,9).…”

Managerial competencies – A survey of hospital managers’ working in Kathmandu valley, Nepal

“…The demographics of the respondents suggest that the women were less involved in the managerial positions of hospital management as this finding is similar to the study of the Pillay [12] . The majority of the respondents were from the non-administrative academic discipline and have had no any formal training attained in hospital management responsible for managing hospital in the Kathmandu Valley.…”

Assessing performance of Botswana’s public hospital system: the use of the World Health Organization Health System Performance Assessment Framework

“…Clear job descriptions for both cadres are necessary for the smooth running of the hospitals. Appropriate training of these managers is also important (47,48).…”