The Sincerest Form of Flattery: Nationalist Emulation during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

As COVID-19 rapidly spread across the globe, every government in the world has been forced to enact policies to slow the spread of the virus. While leaders often claim responses are based on the best available advice from scientists and public health experts, recent policy diffusion research suggests that countries are emulating the COVID-19 policies of their neighbors instead of responding to domestic conditions. Political and geographic considerations play a role in determining which countries imitate one another, but even among countries that are politically or geographically distant, nationalist regimes seem to favor certain approaches towards the pandemic. We investigate why this is the case by examining whether countries that embrace a nationalist ideology are more likely to emulate the COVID-19 policies of similarly nationalist regimes. We demonstrate that, even after controlling for domestic circumstances and linguistic, trade, geographic, and political connections, nationalist countries are emulating each other’s responses. These results are robust and shed light not only on new mechanisms of policy diffusion but also on the growing international cooperation of nationalist regimes and leaders.

COVID-19 and the Wuhan Diary –how does the overseas Chinese community react to group criticism?

“…The rise of nationalism on a global scale during COVID-19 has become a big concern [ 8 , 20 , 21 , 28 – 34 ]. While the nationalist sentiment reflected in the debate about the Wuhan Diary has been most intense in China, it sent ripples through Chinese communities worldwide.…”

The Struggle for Certainty: Ontological Security, the Rise of Nationalism, and Australia-China Tensions after COVID-19

“…The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated a wave of nationalism that has been growing in intensity over the last decade, reinforcing preexisting nationalist and protectionist waves [1,30]. Exclusionary nationalism during the COVID-19 pandemic has increased the decoupling of international exchanges, adversely affecting the strategic environment in which Australia acts as a middle power.…”

Contagious Policies? Studying National Responses to a Global Pandemic in Europe

“…Recent research on policy‐making during the Covid‐19 pandemic has found evidence that governments have been influenced by the policy choices of other governments and have drawn lessons from each other. Yet these studies focus either on a single case study such as Cyprus (Petridou et al 2020), on nationalist regimes in different world regions that have emulated each other (Givens and Mistur 2021), or on factors such as government capacity, societal trust, or party preferences that may have caused variety among national responses (Toshkov et al 2020), rather than on the patterns and mechanisms of policy diffusion.…”