“…Similarly, Robert Gay (2009) describes how the 'favelas of hope' he studied in Rio, which had been characterized by vibrant grassroots organizations in the past, become 'favelas of despair', dominated by extralegal armed actors spreading terror and mistrust. An equivalent picture emerges from other contemporary studies of Rio de Janeiro's slums (for example, Goldstein, 2003;Penglase, 2005;Arias, 2006;McCann, 2006), as well as studies of slums and shantytowns in other Latin American cities (for example, Goldstein, 2004;Hume, 2009;Moser, 2009).…”