The shrinking world of girls at puberty: Violence and gender-divergent access to the public sphere among adolescents in South Africa

Abstract

Participatory mapping was undertaken with single-sex groups of grade 5 and grade 8–9 children in KwaZulu-Natal. Relative to grade 5 students, wide gender divergence in access to the public sphere was found at grade 8–9. With puberty, girls’ worlds shrink, while boys’ expand. At grade 5, female-defined community areas were equal or larger in size than those of males. Community area mapped by urban grade 8–9 girls, however, was only one-third that of male classmates and two-fifths that of grade 5 girls. Conversely, community area mapped by grade 8–9 boys was twice that of grade 5 boys. Similar differences emerged in the rural site. No female group rated a single community space as more than ‘somewhat safe’. Although curtailed spatial access is intended to protect girls, grade 8–9 girls reported most places in their small navigable areas as very unsafe. Expanded geographies of grade 8–9 boys contained a mix of safe and unsafe places. Reducing girls’ access to the public sphere does not increase their perceived safety, but may instead limit their access to opportunities for human development. The findings emphasize the need for better violence prevention programming for very young adolescents.

More Than Brides Alliance: Baseline report, Niger

“…We know from previous research that as girls get older their worlds shrink compared to their male peers (Hallman et al 2015) and our findings suggest that girls in our research have limited mobility. Overall 75.2% of respondents reported that they could not go out after sunset, with significant differences by region (85.3% in Tillaberi and 54.8% in Maradi).…”

More Than Brides Alliance: Baseline report, Mali

“…We know from previous research that once girls get older their worlds shrink compared to their male peers (Hallman et al 2015) and our findings suggest that girls in our research have limited mobility. Overall, 66.6% of respondents reported that they could not go out after sunset (no difference by region).…”

Examining early marriage in India: Qualitative findings

“…We know from previous research that girls' mobility relative to the mobility of their male peers tends to shrink at puberty (Hallman et al 2015). We inquired about adolescent girls' mobility, seeking to understand where girls are allowed to go and how this is influenced by age and marital status.…”