The Rule of Law as the Measure of Political Legitimacy in the Greek City States

Abstract

This paper explores how a conception of the rule of law (embodied in a variety of legal and political institutions) came to affirm itself in the world of the ancient Greek city states. It argues that such a conception, formulated in opposition to the arbitrary rule of man, was to a large extent consistent with modern ideas of the rule of law as a constraint to political power, and to their Fullerian requirements of formal legality, as well as to requirements of due process. The article then analyses how this ideal was formulated in the Archaic period, and how it became a key feature of Greek identity. Finally, it argues that in the fifth and fourth centuries BCE it came to be used as the measure of the legitimacy of Greek political systems: democracy and oligarchy, as they engaged in an ideological battle, were judged as legitimate (and desirable) or illegitimate (and undesirable) on the basis of their conformity with a shared ideal of the rule of law. Then as now, to quote Tamanaha, 'the rule of law' was 'an accepted measure worldwide of government legitimacy'.

What’s Wrong with Democracy? The Peculiar Power of Kratos

“…Jacques Rancière describes this condition of modern politics as 'democracy corrected,' for which constitutional protections and practices of governance "allow the people to enjoy the visibility of their power through the dispersal and even delegation of their qualities and prerogatives." 10 Complaints about amathia re-emerge in contemporary writers like Jason Brennan, who heaps scorn upon the guilelessness of 'Hobbits' and 'Hooligans' (in Brennan's clumsy typology), for which he proposes greater deference to the resolute expertise of 'Vulcans.' 11 Those unpersuaded by the call for epistocracy see equivalent dangers arising from the structural ataxia of the electoral system, and see viciously competitive partisanship as the real instigator of civil unrest.…”

Driving Learning Policies and Legal Regulations for Transferring the Ancient Site Mission

“…Actions must be made by the concept of the rule of law governing the legitimacy of the administrative department (Canevaro, 2017), namely the "principle of no law, no power" that requires government agencies to take any action only if the law provides for them, and the opinion of the Board of Regents, 25/2006 on compliance with the Local Government Planning and Procedures Act, 1999 (in the case of the management of the care of antiquities, antiquities, national museums and archives in the Municipality of Ayutthaya), and as amended (No. 2) B.E.…”

Wpływ regulacji międzynarodowych na ograniczenia w kształtowaniu się ustrojów totalitarnych, autorytarnych i dyktatur

“…Szczególnie negatywnie w tym zestawieniu prezentowana była Persja. Niemniej jednak nawet w samych Atenach zdarzało się, że władza była przekazywana w ręce jednej osoby, choć sprawowanie tych wyjątkowych funkcji było ograniczone czasowo, a wyjątkowo surowo byli karani ci, którzy nie przestrzegali wówczas prawa 10 . Kolejnym obostrzeniem było pozbawienie takiej osoby szerokich kompetencji prawotwórczych.…”