The role of subnational cultural value on animosity: the China-South Korea THAAD crisis

Abstract

PurposeThis study examines the impact of situational and stable animosities on quality evaluation and purchase intention while also testing the moderating effects of within- and cross-country cultural distance. It focuses on the case of the US THAAD missile defense system deployment in South Korea (hereafter, Korea) and investigates how the resulting Chinese consumers' animosity affects their quality evaluation of, and purchase intention toward, Korean cosmetics.Design/methodology/approachThis study utilizes a quantitative approach based on a survey and structural equation modeling. The sample comprises 376 Chinese consumers from 19 Chinese regions.FindingsThe results indicate that both stable and situational animosities are negatively associated with purchase intention toward Korean cosmetics. However, their effects on quality evaluation are different. While stable animosity is negatively related to product quality evaluation, situational animosity has no such negative association. Finally, the cultural distance between Chinese regions and Korea strengthens the negative relationship between stable and situational animosities and purchase intention.Research limitations/implicationsThe study contributes by better unraveling the effects of stable and situational animosities on perceived product quality. The empirical context is unique because it allows the authors to investigate the relationship between Chinese antagonism toward the THAAD deployment in Korea and Chinese consumers' stable and situational animosities in terms of their quality evaluation of, and purchase intention toward, imported Korean cosmetics. Hence, this study contributes to the literature on consumer animosity by empirically testing the moderating effect of within- and cross-country cultural distance on the relationship between stable and situational animosities and purchase intention.Practical implicationsThe study has relevant practical implications, notably for Korean exporters' marketing management and within- and cross-cultural management. The results suggest that countermeasures are needed because Chinese consumers' stable and situational animosities are negatively related to their purchase intention toward Korean cosmetics. Moreover, the findings provide the insight that when foreign firms export culture-sensitive products to a large, multicultural country, their managers should pay attention to within- and cross-cultural differences simultaneously.Originality/valuePrevious studies have shown that the effects of animosity on product evaluation and purchase intention differ depending on the animosity dimension, product type, country and the situation causing animosity, among others. However, the existing literature on animosity has neglected the reality that within-cultural differences in a single large emerging market are relevant to explaining the concept of animosity and its effect on the purchase intention toward culture-sensitive products. Furthermore, none of the animosity studies have touched on the important moderating role of within- and cross-cultural differences between a large and multicultural importing country and a brand's home country in this manner. Therefore, the study fills this gap by empirically examining whether different moderating effects of stable and situational animosities exist for a specific conflict situation caused by a military issue and investigates the causes of these different effects.

Effects of consumer animosity on boycotts: the role of cognitive-affective evaluations and xenocentrism

“…It investigated the influence of brand animosity on boycott intention and the mediation role of cognitive and affective evaluation. First, consistent with previous findings, consumer animosity was found to directly affect purchase intentions (Klein et al , 1998; Lee and Chon, 2021; Lee et al , 2021; Saini and Parayitam, 2020). Consumers' brand animosity could directly lead to boycotts of related fashion products.…”

“…The empirical results of this study showed that brand animosity has a significant negative impact on product judgments. The controversy regarding whether animosity negatively influences perceptions of product quality may be attributed to the varying types of animosity assessed across studies, with stable animosity and situational animosity having been found to have different effects on quality judgments (Lee et al , 2021; Leong et al , 2008).…”

Unlocking the gender diversity–group performance link: the moderating role of relative cultural distance

“…Third, the mainstream international management research still includes the composite cultural distance index proposed by Kogut and Singh (1988) to synthetically evaluate cultural distance (e.g. Ding et al, 2022;Lee et al, 2021;Li et al, 2021). Indeed, this index is one of the most popular measures based on Hofstede's country-level cultural dimension deviation (which is consistent with our choice of adopting Hofstede's theoretical framework).…”

Evaluation of the National Values Construction Program for National Resilience Institute Republic of Indonesia (LEMHANNAS RI)

“…In the Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary of Current English [7] evaluation is to find out, decide the amount or value. Evaluation activities must be carried out carefully, responsibly, using strategies and can be accounted for [8].…”