The role of recollection and familiarity in visual working memory: A mixture of threshold and signal detection processes.

Abstract

Whether working memory reflects a thresholded recollection process whereby only a limited number of items are maintained in memory, or a signal detection process in which each studied item is increased in familiarity strength, is a topic of considerable debate. A review of visual working memory studies that have examined receiver operating characteristics (ROCs) across a broad set of materials and test conditions indicates that both signal detection and threshold processes contribute to working memory. In addition, the role that these two processes play varies systematically across conditions, such that a threshold process plays a particularly critical role when binary old/new judgments are required, when changes are relatively discrete, and when the hippocampus does not contribute to performance. In contrast, a signal detection process plays a greater role when confidence judgments are required, when the materials or the changes are global in nature, and when the hippocampus contributes to performance. In addition, the ROC results indicate that in standard single-probe tests of working memory, items that are maintained in an active recollected state support both recall-to-accept and recall-to-reject responses; whereas in complex-probe tests, recollection preferentially supports recall-to-reject; and in item-recognition tests it preferentially supports recall-to-accept. Moreover, there is growing evidence that these threshold and strength-based processes are related to distinct states of conscious awareness whereby they support perceiving- and sensing-based responses, respectively.

Perceptual Boost of Visual Memorability on Visual Memory Formation

“…Finally, while our data suggest that memorable content may be processed in a more advantage state, it remains to be determined if these memorability benefits are linked with increased memory strength or fidelity across both VSTM and VLTM-a theoretically important issue concerning how memorable stimuli are represented in visual memory. Future research using signal detection models may be useful to address this question (Xie & Zhang, 2017a;Yonelinas, 2023).…”