The Role of Nonemployers in Business Dynamism and Aggregate Productivity

Abstract

A well-documented observation of the U.S. economy in the last few decades has been the steady decline in the net entry rate of employer firms, a decline in business dynamism, suggesting a possible connection with the recent slowdown in aggregate productivity growth. We consider the role of nonemployers, businesses without paid employees, in business dynamism and aggregate productivity. Notwithstanding the decline in the growth of employer firms, we show that the total number of firms, which includes nonemployer businesses, has increased in the U.S. economy since the early 1980s. We interpret this trend, along with the evolution of the employment distribution across firms, through the lens of a standard theory of firm dynamics. The model implies that firm dynamics have contributed to an average annual growth rate of aggregate productivity of at least 0.26% since the early 1980s, over one quarter of the productivity growth of 1% in the data. Further, our implied measure of productivity growth moves closely over time with measured productivity growth in the data.

Synergizing Ventures

“…The quality of early patenting is measured by the total number of citations for all 11 Most likely, these …rms receive VC funding at a stage when they are still non-employers; i.e., businesses with no payroll/employees. Recent work by Bento and Restuccia (2019) highlights the contribution of non-employer businesses to business dynamism in the United States.…”

Solo self‐employment––Key policy challenges

“…However, trends occurring during the first two decades of the 21st century appear to confirm the secular downward trend in self-employment (Boeri et al, 2020;Bento & Restuccia, 2019). Naudé (2022) argued that the anticipation of the "entrepreneurial revolution" has not materialized and the term "ossified" better characterizes the current status of self-employment in developed economies.…”

Labour Costs and the Decision to Hire the First Employee

“…Herein lies a paradox: new employers are the driving force of job creation, but only a tiny fraction of nonemployers will ever become employers. In 2014, nonemployers accounted for 82% of all firms in the US (Bento and Restuccia, 2019). However, while the share of nonemployers has steadily increased over the last three decades, the rate at which nonemployers become employers has slowed down.…”