The reactions of substituted 1-phenylpyrazoles (phpyz-H) at [MCl 2 Cp*] 2 dimers (M = Rh, Ir; Cp* = C 5 Me 5 ) in the presence of NaOAc to form cyclometalated Cp*M(phpyz)-Cl were studied experimentally and with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. At room temperature, time-course and H/D exchange experiments indicate that product formation can be reversible or irreversible depending on the metal, the substituents, and the reaction conditions. Competition experiments with both para-and meta-substituted ligands show that the kinetic selectivity favors electron-donating substituents and correlates well with the Hammett parameter giving a negative slope consistent with a cationic transition state. However, surprisingly, the thermodynamic selectivity is completely opposite, with substrates with electron-withdrawing groups being favored. These trends are reproduced with DFT calculations that show C−H activation proceeds by an AMLA/CMD mechanism. H/D exchange experiments with the meta-substituted ligands show ortho-C−H activation to be surprising facile, although (with the exception of F substituents) this does not generally lead to orthocyclometalated products. Calculations suggest that this can be attributed to the difficulty of HOAc loss after the C−H activation step due to steric effects in the 16e intermediate that would be formed. Our study highlights that the use of substituent effects to assign the mechanism of C−H activation in either stoichiometric or catalytic reactions may be misleading, unless the energetics of the C−H cleavage step and any subsequent reactions are properly taken into account. The broader implications of our study for the assignment of C−H activation mechanisms are discussed.