“…A large number of studies found that the presence of MNCs contributed to TFP growth via spillovers from both horizontal and vertical linkages with MNCs (Ramirez 2006;Suyanto, Salim and Bloch;Fernandes and Paunov, 2012;Anwar and Nguyen, 2014) across various levels of aggregation (Liu and Wang, 2003;Peluffo, 2015;Herzer, 2013Herzer, , 2017Mühlen and Escobar, 2019;). These impacts manifested by raising the industrial competitiveness of manufacturing, by contributing to labour-movement into productive manufacturing and services or simply due to the higher productivity of foreign firms (Fan and Hu, 2007;Lin, Lee and Yang, 2011;Fan, Hu and Kwan, 2019).…”