The role of emotion regulation, coping, self‐reflection and insight in staff interaction with patients with a diagnosis of personality disorder in forensic settings

Abstract

Accessible summary What is known on the subject? Interaction between staff and patients with a diagnosis of personality disorder in forensic settings is important for quality of care, but research is lacking on what determines this interaction. What the paper adds to existing knowledge? Insight, emotion‐focused coping and emotion regulation of staff influence the interaction between staff and these patients. Staff who understand their own thoughts, feelings and behaviour better (more insight) needed less support, encouragement or back‐up from their patients. Staff who cope by getting upset, blaming themselves or fantasizing about solutions (emotion‐focused coping) on the contrary needed more support from their patients. Emotion regulation had an impact on the relation between coping and hostile staff behaviour. When staff get upset (emotion‐focused coping) and try to think differently about the situation (reappraisal), this makes them behave in a more hostile manner towards their patients. When staff suppress their emotions and also distract themselves or engage in social activities (avoidance‐focused coping), they behave in a less hostile manner towards their patients. What are the implications for practice? In order to provide compassionate care for their patients, staff ought to be trained in self‐compassion. This may help them not to get upset, blame themselves or fantasize about solutions and to understand their own thoughts, feelings and behaviour better. As a result, staff may need less support, encouragement or back‐up from their patients. Context is important: Staff ought to suppress their emotions when emotions run high, but only when they also care for themselves by distracting themselves or engaging in social activities. Facing and regulating their emotions by changing what they think about the situation (reappraisal) may be more appropriate once emotions have settled down. This may help staff to remain compassionate towards their patients in the long run and avoid burn‐out or compassion fatigue due to ignoring their own needs and boundaries. Abstract IntroductionResearch is lacking on what determines interaction between staff and patients with a diagnosis of personality disorder in forensic settings. AimTo test whether coping, self‐reflection, insight and emotion regulation are related to the behaviour of staff towards these patients, and to test the possible moderating and mediating effect of emotion regulation. MethodUsing a cross‐sectional design, 76 direct care staff of a forensic clinic completed questionnaires on all variables. Relations were tested using simple linear regression, mediation and moderation analyses. ResultsInsight and emotion‐focused coping of staff were related to seeking less and more support from patients, respectively. Emotion regulation by reappraisal combined with emotion‐focused coping was associated with more hostile behaviour by staff, and suppression combined with avoidance‐focused coping with less hostile behaviour. ConclusionInsight, emotion‐focused copin...

Engaging with distress: Training in the compassionate approach

“…CMT is an emotion‐regulation intervention and for this reason hypothesized to be particularly useful within high‐stress work environments such as mental healthcare settings. Indicatively, a recent study (Oostvogels, Bongers, & Willems, 2018) showed that emotion‐focused coping and emotion‐regulation influenced the interaction between staff and patients with a personality disorder diagnosis, helping them to offer compassionate care and to avoid burnout. In a discussion of the design of compassionate care, Crawford et al (2014) suggest that providing a welcoming environment, promoting bidirectional compassion, providing training in compassion to healthcare professionals and involving service users, practitioners and leaders in creating supportive organizational structures might engender more compassionate and ethical working environments.…”

An integrative review exploring the experiences of service users carrying a diagnosis of personality disorder and student mental health nurses and the time they share together

“…This includes good multidisciplinary working and group supervision utilising a reflective approach. Reflective discussion was recommended in Oostvogels, Bongers, and Willems (2018) study to enhance compassionate behaviour of practitioners working with service users with a personality disorder diagnosis. Yildiz (2019) highlight students' need for supervision due to their encounter of communication barriers when caring for service users and experiencing the effects of countertransference.…”

Meanings of carers’ lived experience of “regulating oneself” in forensic psychiatry

“…Gross ( 1998 ) argued an early strategy in this process, which is referred to as emotional regulation, implies suppressing or reappraising one’s emotions. This is strongly correlated with carers’ behaviour towards forensic patients, as they become less antagonistic by reducing self-criticism and increasing self-compassion (Oostvogels et al, 2018 ). Carers who avoid dealing with and managing their emotions risk becoming distanced, detached or disengaged (Oates et al, 2020 ).…”