The role of consultative alliance in infant and early childhood mental health consultation: Child, teacher, and classroom outcomes

Abstract

Young children's social-emotional development is powerfully shaped by their early environments, which for many includes early childhood education (ECE). Infant and Early Childhood Mental Health Consultation (IECMHC) pairs teachers and infant and early childhood mental health (IECMH) consultants to promote teachers' capacity to foster positive social-emotional development in ECE. Although the outcomes of IECMHC have been well studied, little research has investigated how this model leads to changes for teachers and children. According to theory, the quality of the relationship between teachers and IECMH consultants, termed consultative alliance (CA), is a key mechanism of change. This study analyzed the role of CA on 6-month outcomes of IECMHC in a sample of 316 children, 289 teachers, and 62 IECMH consultants. Results from multilevel models suggested that stronger CA predicted greater improvements in teacherchild closeness and teacher-rated child attachment behaviors. In addition, a strong CA was related to greater improvement in classroom climate, teachers' self-efficacy, and teachers' perceptions of their jobs. This study upholds the centrality of relationship-building and parallel process in mental health consultation, and by advancing understanding of the mechanisms of change for IECMHC may provide salient implications for policy and practice. K E Y W O R D S infant and early childhood mental health consultation, consultative alliance, teacher-child relationship, teacher well-being 246

Current Needs of Preschool Teachers for Professional Development in Greece: A Focus Group Study

“…Teacher-student relationships are often mentioned as one of the core reasons for staying in the profession (O'Connor 2010). Furthermore, the professional development has also been shown to be related to improved teachers' well-being, self--efficacy, sense of autonomy, and reduction in burnout levels (Davis et al, 2021;Sandilos et al, 2020;Wolf et al, 2018). Similarly, research has shown that support provided by the school leadership, is an important defining factor for retention and commitment to the teaching profession (Beltman et al, 2018;Peixoto et al, 2018).…”

Implementing Banking Time with Teachers and Preschoolers Displaying Disruptive Behaviors: Links Between Consultant-Teacher Relationship Quality, Implementation Fidelity and Dosage, and Dyadic Teacher–Child Interactions

“…Recent research on an infant and early childhood mental health consultation program supports this notion of a parallel process. Specifically, a stronger consultative alliance (defined as the quality of the partnership between a consultant and teacher) was linked to greater improvements in teachers' perceptions of close relationships with children (Davis et al, 2021). A strong relationship between a consultant and teacher could similarly influence dyadic teacher-child interactions.…”

Starting Strong VI

“…The differences in staff educational attainment at these two levels of ECEC reflect the different value placed on education versus care, despite their interwoven nature in ECEC settings. This distinction also comes into play in different training profiles among teachers and assistants, even within the preprimary sector (Van Laere, Peeters and Vandenbroeck, 2012 [67]).…”

“…staff-child interactions, staff motivation for achieving the centre goals, community and parental/guardian engagement), as well as on management and administrative tasks (e.g. hiring staff, managing budgets) (Daniëls, Hondeghem and Dochy, 2019 [67]; Douglass, 2018 [68]). While different dimensions of leadership are important for quality, pedagogical leadership, depending on the context and situation, can play an important role in shaping everyday classroom practices (Halpern, Szecsi and Mak, 2020[69]).…”

“…Source: OECD "Quality beyond Regulations" database.Besides initial training, leaders need to develop their skills and knowledge through professional development, which can favour changes in the ideas and practices of ECEC leaders. Professional development can promote a shift in leadership approaches, positively impacting leaders' abilities to facilitate and implement developmentally appropriate strategies (Daniëls, Hondeghem and Dochy, 2019[67]; Page and Eadie, 2019[70];Myran and Masterson, 2020…”