The rise of cancer in urban India: Cultural understandings, structural inequalities and the emergence of the clinic

Abstract

Cancer services in India have evolved and expanded significantly in recent years, with a surge in the availability of biomedical oncological treatment facilities for certain cohorts of the Indian population in urban areas. Despite significant and sustained economic development in many areas of India, major issues persist in the delivery of cancer care, even in the context of relatively prosperous urban populations. This article explores the dilemmas evident in Indian cancer care as perceived by a group of Indian oncology clinicians. Specifically, the interviews focused on their perspectives on the key challenges facing cancer patients, particularly in relation to help-seeking and access to care. The main concerns that emerged in the interviews were: (a) practical constraint (i.e. access and treatment); (b) cultural values (i.e. communication, stigma and the clinic); and (c) structural conditions (i.e. inequalities related to place, gender and class). We unpack these as important elements of cancer care in contemporary India, and present Farmer's notion of structural violence, among other concepts, as potentially useful for understanding some facets of this social problem. We conclude that without a greater understanding of social and cultural issues shaping cancer care in India, little progress will be made in coping with a disease that is set to become a major burden within an increasingly prosperous and ageing population.

The sociology of cancer: a decade of research

“…Bourret et al . ), with only three articles considering low to middle income countries (Broom and Doron (India); Gibbon ; (Brazil and Cuba)).…”

A qualitative exploration of cervical and breast cancer stigma in Karnataka, India

“…Stigma is increasingly recognized as a critical psychosocial barrier to, and key social determinant of, health [ 14 ], its negative impact on health most clearly documented in the field of HIV [ 15 – 21 ]. Recognition of the potential role of stigma to similarly undermine the cancer care continuum [ 22 ], particularly cervical and breast cancer prevention, screening, and treatment [ 10 , 11 , 13 , 23 , 24 ], is beginning to grow, though empirical evidence is still limited. The importance of recognizing and exploring cancer related stigma in India is also gaining attention [ 13 , 22 , 24 ].…”

“…A review on underutilization of cervical cancer prevention services in LMICs, including India, identified stigma attached to discussing reproductive health issues as a barrier to knowledge of cervical cancer and its prevention [ 11 ]. A qualitative study on challenges to cancer treatment in India identified cultural values and stigma as key barriers to treatment [ 10 ], while a qualitative study in Thailand found that women faced social stigma and isolation following breast cancer treatment [ 25 ]. Another qualitative study conducted in India found that social stigma as a result of believing breast health problems were a reflection of poor character contributed to hiding breast cancer symptoms [ 26 ].…”

Multilevel model of stigma and barriers to cancer palliative care in India: a qualitative study

“…Research is thus needed to identify the best ways to help guide physician–patient and physician–family communication 17. Understanding cultural beliefs that shape access and delivery of cancer palliative care in India is essential to formulating an appropriate response,18 but unfortunately, very little data currently exist to inform such a response. A qualitative study of oncologists in India suggests poor understanding among patients of the meaning of a cancer diagnosis, fear of contagion and hopelessness in face of the diagnosis,19 with professionals sharing information with family members who then often make care decisions without involving the patient.…”