The Relative Incidence of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury in Men and Women at the United States Naval Academy

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relative risk of anterior cruciate ligament injury in female versus male midshipmen at the United States Naval Academy. From 1991 to 1997, we recorded the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament injury during intercollegiate athletics, intramural athletics, and military training. The subjects were male and female varsity athletes, coed intramural athletes, and participants in military training consisting of the obstacle course and instructional wrestling. All patient data were collected at the time of injury. Records filed at the intramural sports office, along with a questionnaire completed by coaches and trainers, were used to estimate midshipmen exposures. Results showed that in intercollegiate soccer, basketball, and rugby, women had a relative injury risk of 3.96 compared with men. In coed soccer, basketball, softball, and volleyball, the women's relative injury risk was 1.40 compared with men. In military training, women had a relative injury risk of 9.74 compared with men. In comparing overall annual anterior cruciate ligament injury rates among midshipmen, we found that women had a relative injury risk of 2.44 compared with men. We concluded that female midshipmen have an increased relative risk of anterior cruciate ligament injury as compared with men in intercollegiate athletics, basic military training, and throughout their service academy career. This increase was not statistically significant at the intramural level of athletics.

Validation of Porcine Knee as a Sex-specific Model to Study Human Anterior Cruciate Ligament Disorders

“…The risk of ACL injury has been shown to be dependent on sex, with women being at a two-to 10-fold greater risk than men when playing the same sport [4,5,23,31,36,41,50,54]. The high risk of injury in women along with their increased rate of sports participation during the last three decades has led to a rapid increase in ACL injuries among women.…”

Lower Limb Coordination and Stiffness During Landing from Volleyball Block Jumps

“…Not surprisingly, the incidence of ACL injury is relatively high in sports involving a high frequency of landing, decelerating and rapid changes of direction such as basketball, netball, handball and volleyball (Arendt and Dick, 1995;Griffin, Angel, Albohm, et al 2000). The incidence of non-contact ACL injury has been reported to be 6 to 8 times greater in females than in males competing in the same sports (Arendt and Dick 1995;Chandy and Grana 1985;Ferretti, Papandrea, Conteduca, et al 1992;Gray, Taunton, McEnzie, et al 1985;Gwinn, Wilkens, McDevitt, et al 2000;Lindenfeld, Schmitt, Hendy, et al 1994;Malone, Hardaker, Garrett, et al 1993).…”

The Sports Bra, the ACL, and Title IX — The Game in Play

“…ACL injuries are more common in boys and men Fact: Certainly, this was true prior to Title IX, but now with an integrated athletic landscape, the rate of ACL injuries is more common in women [1,4,8]. The rate of ACL surgery, however, is more common in men [4,6]. The reasons behind these differences expand the confines of this column, but deal both with sex (biology) and gender (society's ascribed role of sex) [7].…”