The relationship between women's paid employment and women's stated son preference in India

Abstract

OBJECTIVEWe explore whether women's paid employment is associated with reductions in women's stated son preference in India and whether these results vary by employment sector (agriculture, manufacturing, services, professional-technical) and skill level (education and literacy). METHODSWe conduct a logistic regression analysis of the relationship between women's paid employment and women's stated son preference among a sample of never-pregnant Indian women. We use the 2005 India National Family Health Survey (NFHS). RESULTSWomen's paid employment in the service and manufacturing sectors is associated with significant reductions in the stated son preference of low-skilled women (i.e., low education and literacy). However, this negative association goes away for women at higher skill levels. In fact, paid employment in manufacturing is associated with significantly higher stated son preference among university-educated women. However, women's paid employment in agriculture and the professional-technical sectors is not significantly associated with women's stated son preference. Finally, the association between women's paid employment and stated son preference is significantly larger for women living in north India than for women living in south and east India. CONCLUSIONSWe hypothesize that significant negative associations between women's paid employment and women's stated son preference occur only in cases where paid employment changes the economic status of women within the family. CONTRIBUTIONOur analysis demonstrates that there are important linkages between women's paid

Female Employment and Reduction in Family Size in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa

“…However, this was also because employment gave them little time for children's reproduction and socialization. For being in the developing world and famous for a stereotype of only being confronted to the four walls of homes, Pakistan women are now on the breadwinner journey from child-bearer (Behrman, and Duvisac, 2017). Moreover, the late 20 th and early 21 st century provided new opportunities for females.…”

“…The drop in fertility is perceived to be the product of such developments in women's empowerment (Phan, 2013). Moreover, research reveals that depending on the job sector, the relationship between women's paid employment and women's recorded preference for children varies (Behrman, and Duvisac, 2017).…”

Another Gendered Demographic Dividend: Adjusting to a Future without Sons

“…Income growth, poverty reduction, and increases in women's paid employment and wages may create additional pressure for valuing and investing in daughters. Localities with smaller gender pay gaps have lower levels of son preference (Craigie and Dasgupta 2017) and women who work for pay report less son preference (Behrman and Duvisac 2017). 11 Migration may also provide additional demographic pressure.…”

“Daughter-Only” Families in Selected High and Low Son Preference States in India: A Comparative Analysis

“…The association between women’s paid employment and stated son preference is significantly larger for women living in north India than for women living in south and east India. Women’s paid employment and women’s stated son preference occur only in cases where paid employment changes the economic status of women within the family (Behrman & Duvisac, 2017). The sharpest rise in the sex ratio at birth (male/female) with parity found in Punjab followed by Haryana suggests that the discrimination against girls is stronger in Punjab than other Indian States (Das Gupta & Bhat, 1997).…”