The Relationship between Patient-Centered Care and Outcomes in Specialist Drug and Alcohol Treatment: A Systematic Literature Review

Abstract

Background: Patient-centered care is strongly advocated as a key for improving the quality of healthcare. Research examining the impact of patient-centered care in healthcare has concluded that there are demonstrable albeit inconsistent relationships between patient experience, quality of care, and healthcare outcomes. Knowledge of the impact of patient-centered care in the treatment of substance use disorder is limited. The aim of this review was to assess relationships between indicators of patient-centered care (satisfaction and patient-reported experience measures) and patient outcomes (substance use, psychological wellbeing, and service use) among people attending treatment for substance use disorder. Methods: A systematic electronic literature search of a range of databases was conducted with variations of the search terms ‘patient-centered care’, ‘substance use disorders’, and residential or community specialist ‘treatment’. The populations, interventions and outcomes were summarized and described according to the PRISMA statement. Results: A total of 25 articles were identified, of which only five included a patient-centered indicator other than satisfaction. Indicators of patient-centered care showed a generally positive association with improved outcomes, particularly between satisfaction with treatment and substance use. Nonetheless, mixed and contradictory results were not uncommon, more so for psychological wellbeing outcomes. Conclusions: There were demonstrable relationships between patient-centered indicators and outcomes for people receiving treatment for substance use disorder. However, conclusions are limited due to underrepresentation of patient-reported experience measures. Further research in the area is needed involving comparisons of patient centered indicators with outcomes and use of patient-reported experience measures together with satisfaction. Registration number: CRD42018092829

Facilitators and barriers to integrating physical health care during treatment for substance use: A socio‐ecological analysis

“…Among people attending treatment for SUDs, unmet physical health needs have been associated with treatment drop-out, increased risk for relapse and reduced quality of life [8,9]. Patientcentred approaches that respond to the diverse needs of problematic AOD use, including physical health, are widely advocated for [10,11] and are recommended within clinical practice guidelines [12,13]. Research on the effectiveness of integrated care for SUDs has focused predominantly on the integration of AOD treatment and mental health care.…”

“I Felt I Was Reaching a Point with My Health”: Understanding Reasons for Engagement and Acceptability of Treatment Services for Unhealthy Alcohol Use in Primary Care

“…First, being patient-centered was valued, including allowing patients to explore the menu of options available to them given their individual preferences and needs, providing flexibility in terms of interaction with program staff (eg, telehealth), and choice of moderation vs. abstinence goal. Patient-centered care is a key element of SUD treatment and has been found to improve patient outcomes, 56 , 57 and previous research has found that patients value being involved in decisions about their treatment and having autonomy. 25 Therefore, programs should include training and support to program staff on providing patient-centered care.…”

Understanding the client characteristics of Aboriginal residential alcohol and other drug rehabilitation services in New South Wales, Australia

“…Each service offers a range of similar programs that are tailored to local operating guidelines. Research is being undertaken across the six services to consider the role for individual client-focused programs and processes [ 50 ]. From there, a more individual approach could be offered to cater for specific cultural, social and emotional needs of each client.…”