The Relation of Moral Judgment Development and Educational Experience to Recall of Moral Narratives and Expository Texts

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Moral text processing was used as an ecologically valid method for assessing implicit and explicit moral understanding and development. The authors tested undergraduates, seminarians, and graduate students in political science and philosophy for recall of moral narratives and moral expository texts. Multivariate analyses of covariance using educational experience as an independent variable, age and moral judgment score as covariates, and recall of embedded moral arguments as dependent variables revealed a relation between education and level of moral arguments recalled. Lower-stage moral reasoning was best recalled by undergraduates, whereas higher-stage reasoning was best recalled by graduate students, with seminarians intermediate for both types of text. Moral judgment score was related to recall of the highest-level moral arguments even when age and educational experience were controlled. Moral judgment development appeared to be particularly helpful in recall of expository compared with narrative texts.

The emotional foundations of high moral intelligence

“…The notion of expertise development applies to the moral domain as well (Narvaez, 2005(Narvaez, , 2006Narvaez & Gleason, 2007). Paraphrasing the ideas of Aristotle and Mencius, Francisco Varela (1999) wrote: "a wise (or virtuous) person is one who knows what is good and spontaneously does it" (p. 4, emphasis added).…”

The relation of multicultural experiences to moral judgment and mindsets.

“…Moral judgment schemas are used to determine moral action and reasons for action (Rest, Narvaez, Bebeau, & Thoma, 1999), and influence the processing of moral reasoning in discourse (Narvaez, 1998(Narvaez, , 1999. Moral schemas can be mapped developmentally and in terms of expertise (Narvaez & Gleason, 2007). With age and experience, moral judgment schemas shift from a concern for "personal interests" to a concern for "maintaining norms" (status quo) to the ability to think "postconventionally" .…”

Moral development and behaviour under the spotlight of the neurobiological sciences

“…Moral perception involves picking up or apprehending morally-relevant cues in context (Narvaez, 1993;Blum, 1994), which greater expertise facilitates (Narvaez & Gleason, 2007). Moral imagination consists of conceptualising alternative pathways for action as well as possible ramifications from and for those involved (Somerville, 2006).…”