The elimination of tiny amounts of water from alcohols is by no means a trivial issue in many practical applications like, for instance, the dehumidification of biocombustibles. The use of carbonaceous materials as sorbents has been far less explored than that of other materials because their hydrophobic character has typically limited their water uptake. Herein, we designed a synthetic process based on the use of eutectic mixtures that allowed the homogeneous dispersion of graphene oxide (GO) in the liquid containing the carbon precursor-e.g., furfuryl alcohol. Thus, after polymerization and a subsequent carbonization process, we were able to obtain porous carbon-GO composites where the combination of pore diameter and surface area hydrophilicity provided a remarkable capacity for water uptake but extremely low methanol and ethanol uptakes along the entire range of relative pressures evaluated in this work. Both the neat water uptake and the uptake difference between water and both methanol and ethanol of our carbon-GO composites were similar or eventually better that uptakes previously reported for other materials also exhibiting preferential water-to-alcohol adsorption-e.g., porous coordination polymers, MOFs, polyoxometalates, and covalent 2D nanosheets embedded in a polymer matrix. Moreover, water versus alcohol uptakes were particularly remarkable at low partial pressures in our carbon-GO composites.