The range and extent of the Vallesian Crisis (Late Miocene): new prospects based on the micromammal record from the Vallès-Penedès basin (Catalonia, Spain)

Abstract

The Vallesian Crisis was initially recognized as a local event, which implied the extinction of certain rodent and artiodactyl genera coinciding with the early/late Vallesian boundary (at 9.7 Ma). Following works increased the range and extent of this event to encompass all Europe and involve a great number of mammal taxa. Here, we analyze the Vallesian rodent and insectivore record of the Vallès-Penedès basin (Catalonia, Spain), where the crisis was first recognized. We show that the quality of the record before the crisis is comparatively much better than afterwards so diversity appears inflated and extinction rates are overrated. Accordingly, we used inferred taxon ranges and rarefaction to calculate new diversity measures independent of sample size. These measures virtually eliminate the Vallesian Crisis, showing that diversity somewhat decreased during the earliest late Vallesian and soon recovered afterwards. This is because it cannot be discarded that several rare taxa, customarily said to have disappeared during the crisis, are in fact present. Amongst the rodents and insectivores, these taxa include genera that are generally rare and show a discontinuous record during the early Vallesian. These are presumed specialists adapted to humid forested environments such as flying squirrels, beavers or certain dormice, most of them being only recorded when the sample size is large enough. Alternatively, these genera may have been associated to very specific habitats which, for an unknown reason, are not sampled during the late Vallesian. Our results cast serious doubts on the very existence of the Vallesian Crisis suggesting that rather than an abrupt event a series of extinctions occurred during a longer time span. It has not been evaluated whether the same pattern is observed in the case of large mammals and in other areas. However, our results show that biases introduced by the quality of the record need to be taken into account when assessing the extent of the event.Keywords: palaeodiversity, micromammals, Late Miocene, Vallès-Penedès basin, Catalonia, Iberian Peninsula Resumen La Crisis Vallesiense fue inicialmente definida como un fenómeno local que implicó la desaparición de ciertos géneros de roedores y artiodáctilos coincidiendo con el límite entre Vallesiense inferior y superior (hace 9.7 Ma). Trabajos posteriores ampliaron el ámbito y alcance de este evento hasta incluir toda Europa e implicar un gran número de taxones de mamíferos. En este trabajo analizamos el registro Vallesiense de roedores e insectívoros de la cuenca del Vallès-Penedès (Cataluña, España), donde la crisis fue reconocida por primera vez. Se muestra que la calidad del registro fósil con anterioridad a la crisis es comparativamente mucho mejor que la de después de modo que se magnifica la diversidad y se exageran las tasas de extinción. Por lo tanto, se ha utilizado rarefacción y se han inferido rangos estratigráficos a fin de calcular nuevas medidas de diversidad independientes del tamaño de la muestra. Estas medidas elimina...

Siwalik synopsis: A long stratigraphic sequence for the Later Cenozoic of South Asia

“…10 the Siwaliks, with maximum change later in time, after 10 Ma (Agusti et al, 2013;Domingo et al, 2014). After adjusting for unevenness in the fossil record, the Vallesian crisis in the Spanish fossil record is seen to be less abrupt than previously thought, but still significant, and postdates Siwalik events (Casanovas-Vilar et al 2014, 2016. (Tang et al 2015), with decreased micromammal diversity, moist conditions in North China (Fortelius et al, 2014) led to high diversity among both ungulates and small mammals (see also Flynn et al 2011).…”

Regional impacts of global climate change: a local humid phase in central Iberia in a late Miocene drying world

“…The first was the so‐called Vallesian Crisis (early–late Vallesian), first recognized as a local episode in the Catalan coastal basins (Casanovas‐Vilar et al . ). The record of the Alfambra–Teruel Basin shows a number of extinctions that occurred during the late Vallesian (MN10) but over a longer time interval (~9.5–9.1 Ma) than that of the Vallès‐Penedés Basin (van Dam ).…”

Impact of global climate in the diversity patterns of middle Miocene rodents from the Madrid Basin (Spain)

“…Most of the published studies involving calculations of sampling probability and inferred taxon ranges require assigning an absolute age to each locality. Then, the time span studied is divided in 0.1 or 0.5 Myr bins, assigning each locality to a single interval (Barry et al, 2002;Van Dam et al, 2006;Casanovas-Vilar et al, 2014). However, the lack of magnetostratigraphic data in the Madrid Basin (only the localities of Paracuellos and Villaluenga are placed in magnetostratigraphical sections) does not allow us to establish an accurate relative age for each locality.…”