“…Other evidence that discharges to ground develop horizontally in a storm, and that the extent of this development can be considerable, has come from a variety of observations. These consist of photographs of the luminous extent of a discharge [Malan, 1956a], visual and video observations of the luminous development of flashes [Brook and Vonnegut, 1960;Brantley et al, 1975], thunder observations [Sourdillon, 1952;Nakano, 1973Nakano, , 1976Teer and Few, 1974], radar observations of the channel within the cloud [Ligda, 1956], observations of horizontal displacement between the center of charge and the visible channel of flashes to ground [Jacobson and Krider, 1976], and observations of the sources of VHF radiation from discharges' [Proctor, 1976]. Proctor's studies, made in South Africa on storms similar to those studied by M alan and Schonland, showed that the radiation sources of most flashes to ground had large horizontal extents within the cloud and tended to cluster in groups, beginning at or near precipitation boundaries.…”