“…Benthic foraminiferal isotopic measurements from various locations in the deep ocean indicate that intermediate/deep ocean δ 13 C values decreased by 2-3 during the PETM (Bralower et al, 1995;Katz et al, 2001;Kennett and Stott, 1991;Thomas and Shackleton, 1996) while values reflecting the atmosphere/surface ocean reservoir show a larger decrease (Figure 1): 3-4.5 for surface-dwelling planktonic foraminifera (Kelly et al, 1996;Kennett and Stott, 1991;Stott, 1992;Stott et al, 1996;Thomas et al, 2002;Zachos et al, 2003), 4-5 for shallow-water planktonic and benthic foraminifera (Cramer et al, 1999; Cramer and Wright, unpublished data given here), 3.5-5 for organic carbon Knox et al, 2003;Steurbaut et al, 2003), and 6-8 for terrestrial paleosol carbonates and mammalian tooth enamel (Bowen et al, 2001;Koch et al, 2003Koch et al, , 1995Koch et al, , 1992. The discrepancy between the magnitude of the shift in these reservoirs indicates that the carbon isotopic gradient between the surface ocean/atmosphere and deep ocean reservoirs decreased by 1-2 during the PETM.…”