The Prisoner’s Dilemma: An Adequate Concept for Ethical Analysis in Healthcare? A Systematic Search and Critical Review

Abstract

Schools of economic ethics inspired by Buchanan propose viewing ethical conflicts as prisoners’ dilemmas (PDs) to facilitate solutions based on Pareto-improving institutional changes. Given that healthcare is determined by complex institutional arrangements, it has been claimed that this approach is also suitable for business ethics in healthcare. To scrutinize this claim, this research systematically searched for studies reporting PD structures in healthcare. PubMed, EconLit, and EconBiz were searched to find articles in German and English. Study type, characteristics of the game, and the proposed means to overcome the dilemma (if mentioned) were extracted and analyzed for aspects supporting or challenging the claim. Across 53 studies, 68 descriptions of various dilemmas in healthcare and public health were identified. Many authors successfully developed proposals for institutional change to overcome these dilemmas. However, many of these analyses exhibited limitations such as oversimplifications or inconsistencies. Also, the quality of evidence on both the characteristics of dilemmas and the effectiveness of proposed solutions was very poor. The subsamples of studies that explicitly cited the ethical approach were disjunct from those that applied empirical methods to analyze the dilemmas (frequently applying empirically richer frameworks than rational choice only). The large number of identified PDs indicates that economic ethics is relevant to healthcare. However, there is a need for further evidence to substantiate both the descriptive and prescriptive claims of this ethical theory. It should thus be seen as a complement that needs justification, rather than a substitute superior to other ethical frameworks.

A Case Study of European Collaboration between the Veterinary and Human Field for the Development of RSV Vaccines

“…This has led to a higher emphasis on economic considerations and the raising of ethical concerns, putting patients that are seeking healthcare in a vulnerable position. Physicians, therefore, face a specific responsibility to act for the health benefit of their patients [ 27 ]. Our findings confirm that the human field has taken a separate path for the development of vaccines for vulnerable humans, specifically young babies, and is speeding up its R&D, considering the benefits of collaboration with the veterinary professionals as not useful.…”

Influence of Aspects of Extraversion on Information Sharing Within Budget Negotiation

“…Borrowing from behavioral economics the decision is presented as a prisoner's dilemma to reflect the uncertain circumstances inherent in a budget negotiation. Although, to the knowledge of the authors, the prisoner's dilemma structure has not been used in budgeting research before, it is a common structure in judgment and decision-making research to explore the impact of uncertainty (Marinich, 2019;Rogowski and Lange, 2020;Shafir and Tversky, 1992).…”