The preparation phase in the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST): a systematic review and introduction of a reporting checklist

Abstract

Multicomponent behavioral interventions developed using the multiphase optimization strategy (MOST) framework offer important advantages over alternative intervention development models by focusing on outcomes within constraints relevant for effective dissemination. MOST consists of three phases: preparation, optimization, and evaluation. The preparation phase is critical to establishing the foundation for the optimization and evaluation phases; thus, detailed reporting is critical to enhancing rigor and reproducibility. A systematic review of published research using the MOST framework was conducted. A structured framework was used to describe and summarize the use of MOST terminology (i.e., preparation phase and optimization objective) and the presentation of preparation work, the conceptual model, and the optimization. Fifty-eight articles were reviewed and the majority focused on either describing the methodology or presenting results of an optimization trial (n = 38, 66%). Although almost all articles identified intervention components (96%), there was considerable variability in the degree to which authors fully described other elements of MOST. In particular, there was less consistency in use of MOST terminology. Reporting on the MOST preparation phase is varied, and there is a need for increased focus on explicit articulation of key design elements and rationale of the preparation phase. The proposed checklist for reporting MOST studies would significantly advance the use of this emerging methodology and improve implementation and dissemination of MOST. Accurate reporting is essential to reproducibility and rigor of scientific trials as it ensures future research fully understands not only the methodology, but the rationale for intervention and optimization decisions.

Components of smartphone cognitive-behavioural therapy for subthreshold depression among 1093 university students: a factorial trial

“…Several factorial trials of psychological and behavioural complex interventions have been conducted and their results are just starting to be reported. 21 Surprisingly, many studies have failed to find expected effects of specific components or their interactions for various interventions including smoking cessation 22 and iCBT programmes for depression, 23 cancer recurrence fear 24 or alcohol consumption, 25 even when their sample sizes were fairly large.…”

A factorial experiment grounded in the multiphase optimization strategy to promote viral suppression among people who inject drugs on the Texas-Mexico border: a study protocol

“…We have completed phase one ( preparation ) within the MOST framework. The preparation phase activities included leveraging preliminary and formative intervention and qualitative data, literature reviews, expert consultations, and existing programs and staff skills at our primary site (e.g., patient navigation services, staff psychologists) [ 44 ]. The selection of components was based on services currently available but not fully optimized in the sites and the area (i.e., access to MOUD and free ART, staff psychologists who deliver therapy).…”

Human-centered design methods to achieve preparation phase goals in the multiphase optimization strategy framework

“…The Preparation phase provides the critical foundation for the subsequent phases of MOST and cannot be overlooked or undervalued. A recent systematic review by Landoll et al., (2022) proposed a checklist for Preparation phase activities to standardize reporting of this phase of MOST to enhance rigor and reproducibility. Though the checklist ensures Preparation phase activities are reported accurately, the authors note there is room for methodological guidance about accomplishing the goals of this phase.…”