The Precarious Position of the Medical Humanities in the Medical School Curriculum

Abstract

The author contends that bioethics, as currently conceived and taught in most medical schools across the country, should neither be considered as part of nor substituted for the humanities within the curriculum. Arguing that bioethics has evolved into a discipline dominated by rules--which has tilted it more toward scientific methods of reasoning--the author asserts that literature and the fine arts maintain a more humanistic approach rather than focusing on abstract principles. Consequently, the medical humanities and bioethics represent valuable but distinctly different ways of analyzing information, viewing the world, confronting dilemmas, and teaching students. The author stresses both the affective and the cognitive skills gained from incorporating the humanities formally within a medical education environment and shows how including literature and the fine arts emphasizes medicine as a profession rather than merely a trade. Incorporating these disciplines legitimizes individual questioning and collective probing that, in turn, motivate practitioners and students to confront fundamental questions about both their chosen field and their particular places within it. Thus, within the required educational curriculum structured discussions exploring a broad range of medical humanities can play a crucial role that can be neither emulated nor replicated by studying bioethics. Including the medical humanities as part of health care professional's basic training remains pivotal in helping to shape his or her future, both as a compassionate practitioner and as a reflective human being.

Creative Problem Solving and Social Cooperation of Effective Physical Therapy Practice: A Pioneer Study and Overview

“…This led not only to conflict within the group dynamics, but also undermined the actual practice of physical therapy and restricted active participation to a limited number of "participants". At the end of the case presentation and discussion, the "participants" were asked to provide a reflective report as encouraged by others [17,18] including a detailed description (verbal and written) of how social and group dynamics can contribute to the practice of physical therapy. The three outside observers and the lecturer then shared their observations with the group and commented on the overall group dynamics.…”

Students' perspectives about the medical humanities curriculum at the Catholic University of Korea

“…29 This study aims at examining perspectives of changes in student behavior as a first step in the evaluation of the OMNIBUS curriculum. The next study will examine the fundamental question of whether significant resources allocated to the medical humanities curriculum in South Korea can lead to improved student outcomes.…”

Emphasizing humanities in medical education: Promoting the integration of medical scientific spirit and medical humanistic spirit

“…The humanities also have a non-instrumental function when they lead to general education, personal development, or new ways of thinking beyond the biomedical perspective (14,15). For example, study of the humanities has been used to develop self-reflexivity and understanding of the role of the professional in society (16).…”