The politics of evidence on ‘domestic terrorists’: Obesity discourses and their effects

Abstract

The recent construction of an 'obesity epidemic' has been fueled by epidemiologically-based studies recuperated by the media and suggesting the rapid acceleration of obesity rates in the Western world. Studies linking obesity to ill-health have also exploded with more recipes on how to wage 'a war' on obesity and dispose of 'domestic terrorists.' In this paper, we assert that the fabrication of 'evidence' in obesity research constitutes a good example of micro-fascism at play in the contemporary scientific arena. Favoring a particular ideology and excluding alternative forms of knowledge, obesity scientists have established a dominant 'obesity discourse' within which obese and 'at-risk' bodies are constructed as lazy and expensive bodies that should be submitted to disciplinary technologies (for example, surveillance), expert investigation and regulation. Using a poststructuralist approach, we examine the politics of evidence in obesity science and explore the connections between obesity discourses and the ways in which health and the body are discursively constructed by Canadian youth. Social Theory & Health (2010) 8, 259-279. doi:10.1057/sth.2009 Keywords: body; obesity; health; youth; discourse analysis; poststructuralist theory Obesity and 'Evidence'Few North Americans will have escaped the avalanche of scientific and public comments about obesity in recent years. Escalating concerns over an 'obesity epidemic' have been fueled by the epidemiological, physiological and medical r

Obesity management: what brings success?

“…Although the upward trend in the prevalence of obesity was noticed 30 years ago, it is not until recently that obesity and its consequences have become fully acknowledged as a worldwide burden. With political leadership we can declare a 'war' on obesity, nevertheless we have to remember that obese individuals are not 'domestic terrorists' [Rail et al 2010].…”

Sedentarismo, Deporte Y La Presión Biopolítica De Vivir Saludable: Análisis Del Discurso Del Sistema Elige Vivir Sano en Chile

“…Estos son higiene (PEDRAZA, 2011), epidemiología (BAGRICHEVSKY;ESTEVÃO, 2012;KELLEY;SMITH, 2004;RAIL;HOLMES;MURRAY, 2010), obesidad (MORALES; FILOMENA; JIM; NORTE; ANDALUZ, 2013;RAIL et al, 2010;RAIL;, VALBUENA et al, 2015WACHS;CHASE, 2013;WARIN, 2010), deporte (MALCOLM, 2014;PIGGIN;BAIRNER, 2014;PIPER;GARRATT, 2012), salud (ARBOLEDA, 2013;MARTÍNEZ, 2011;MORALES et al, 2013;PALACIOS;RICO, 2011;PANIER, 2009) y mercado (ARREGUIN;SANDOVAL, 2014;SOSSA, 2011). Estas investigaciones permitieron contextualizar y abordar la temática de una manera profunda.…”

The Barker hypothesis and obesity: Connections for transdisciplinarity and social justice

“…Stereotypes that fat people are uneducated, weak-willed and immoral (Campos et al, 2006;Boero, 2007;Throsby, 2007) in 'choosing' to be fat or denying their 'real' eating and exercising habits (Herndon, 2008) occlude the 'epidemic' in moral panic (Fraser et al, 2010;Rail et al, 2010). The war on obesity therefore attaches significant social stigma to fatness.…”