The Politico-Economic Challenges of Ghana’s National Health Insurance Scheme Implementation

Abstract

Background: National/social health insurance schemes have increasingly been seen in many low-and middle-income countries (LMICs) as a vehicle to universal health coverage (UHC) and a viable alternative funding mechanism for the health sector. Several countries, including Ghana, have thus introduced and implemented mandatory national health insurance schemes (NHIS) as part of reform efforts towards increasing access to health services. Ghana passed mandatory national health insurance (NHI) legislation (ACT 650) in 2003 and commenced nationwide implementation in 2004. Several peer review studies and other research reports have since assessed the performance of the scheme with positive rating while challenges also noted. This paper contributes to the literature on economic and political implementation challenges based on empirical evidence from the perspectives of the different category of actors and institutions involved in the process. Methods: Qualitative in-depth interviews were held with 33 different category of participants in four selected district mutual health insurance schemes in Southern (two) and Northern (two) Ghana. This was to ascertain their views regarding the main challenges in the implementation process. The participants were selected through purposeful sampling, stakeholder mapping, and snowballing. Data was analysed using thematic grouping procedure. Results: Participants identified political issues of over politicisation and political interference as main challenges. The main economic issues participants identified included low premiums or contributions; broad exemptions, poor gatekeeper enforcement system; and culture of curative and hospital-centric care. Conclusion:The study establishes that political and economic factors have influenced the implementation process and the degree to which the policy has been implemented as intended. Thus, we conclude that there is a synergy between implementation and politics; and achieving UHC under the NHIS requires political stewardship. Political leadership has the responsibility to build trust and confidence in the system by providing the necessary resources and backing with minimal interference in the operations. For sustainability of the scheme, authorities need to review the exemption policy, rate of contributions, especially, from informal sector employees and recruitment criteria of scheme workers, explore additional sources of funding and re-examine training needs of employees to strengthen their competences among others. Implications for policy makers • Within the context of this study, addressing the political and economic challenges of the national health insurance schemes (NHIS) in Ghana requires a policy review of the exemption policy to make it more target-specific. This has the potential of ensuring those who really cannot afford get services. • Contributions from both formal and informal sector employees also need to be marginally adjusted upward including the introduction of some percentage of taxes on alcohol and tobacco product...

What Alternative and Innovative Sources of Healthcare Finance Can be Explored for the Sustainability of the National Health Insurance Scheme of Ghana? Perspectives of Health Managers

“…They think failure by the government and the NHIA to institute appropriate monitoring measures over time could sti e nancial sustainability efforts. Similar studies in Ghana have come out with similar recommendations [13,30]. Detailing this nding is not possible within the scope of this document since it was not the focus.…”

Ascertaining the Influence of Politics on the Outcomes of the Implementation of the NHIS: Study of the Ga West District Mutual Health Insurance Scheme

“…To this extent, implementing decentralization in Ghana wouldn't be effective. On health, (Fusheini, 2016) on his 'Politico-Economic challenges of Ghana's National Health Insurance Scheme Implementation focuses on the economic and political implementation challenges based on empirical evidence from the perspectives of the different category of actors and institutions involved in the process. From his model, the study identifies political issues of over politicization and political interference from ruling party and time and timing of policy changes as main challenges.…”

Implementation challenges of the mandatory health insurance scheme

“…The designing of a scheme is very crucial; in order to achieve a proper balance between efficiency and equity, it is essential to design scheme with attractive benefit packages is necessary (Purohit 2014). To ensure the sustainability of health care scheme, authorities should review the policy of exemption, contributions rate, particularly, from employees from different informal sector and recruitment standards of organization workforces, continuous exploration for additional funding sources, and re-assess the need of training for employees to ensure competence with others (Fusheini 2016).…”