The Political Origins of Religious Liberty

Gill, Anthony J.

doi:10.1017/cbo9780511790805

Cited by 112 publications

(110 citation statements)

References 195 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

101

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The Muslims are allowed to refer to their sharia, similarly, the Christians are allowed to refer to their canonical book as a reference, the Buddhists are justifiable to base their argument on Tri Pitaka and the a-theist groups can use their personal truth to buttress their argument. In brief, every religious adherent of a religious conviction is free to use his or her religious conviction as a reference as well as the basis for argument (Gill 2007). This is different from the idea of free-standing justice of John Rawls which requires justification only from the ideas that are implicit in the political culture (Rawls 2005, 10).…”

Section: Religious Freedom and Islamic State: Gamwellian Approachmentioning

confidence: 99%

Religious Freedom and the Idea of Establishing Islamic State

Hapsin

2017

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The idea of Gamwell on "religion as rational" was based on the concept that religious freedom is nothing other than a political discourse that can be figured out only through a democratic resolution. Changing paradigm from "religion as non-rational" to "religion as rational" is a necessary condition for entering a public debate. Yet, the sole public debate or public view is not enough to solve the modern political problematic. The public debate must be guided by a constitutional procedure affirmed by the body politic so that it fulfills the criteria of formal claim about justice. Applying qualitative research and literature review this research tried to reveal: Gamwell's idea of religious freedom, the features of the Islamic State as described by Abdul Rauf and Gamwell's concept of religious freedom and the idea of establishing the Islamic State advocated by Abdul Rauf. Gagasan Gamwell tentang "agama itu rasional" didasarkan pada konsep bahwa kebebasan beragama tidak lain adalah wacana politik yang hanya bisa diraih melalui resolusi demokratis. Mengubah paradigma dari "agama sebagai tidak rasional" menjadi

show abstract

Section: Religious Freedom and Islamic State: Gamwellian Approachmentioning

confidence: 99%

Religious Freedom and the Idea of Establishing Islamic State

Hapsin

2017

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Neste campo, destacamos os trabalhos de Gorski (2003), Gill (2008), Fox (2008;2015) e Stolz (2010), essencialmente, porque, tal como no modelo do mercado religioso, demonstram a vitalidade das ideias religiosas e das igrejas e comunidades espirituais. Contudo, pela sua proximidade ao tópico central e pela sua intersecção, analisamos apenas as teses de Gill e Fox14.…”

Section: ____________________________________________________________unclassified

Teorias da secularização e o modelo da economia religiosa

Moniz

2017

Cienc. Soc. y Relig.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

ResumoMuito se tem escrito sobre a secularização, mas poucas têm sido as investigações profundas sobre as suas camadas internas e sobre as alternativas mais sólidas e sistemáticas que lhe seguiram. No nosso ver, isto refletiu-se em dificuldades de compreensão interpretativa e de aprofundamento teórico-analítico que são necessárias e possíveis de ultrapassar. Para cumprir tal desiderato, escolhemos um desenho de investigação que engloba as estratégias da descrição densa e do método comparativo e dividimos o trabalho em duas partes essenciais. Em primeiro lugar, analisamos os principais substratos da secularização, nomeadamente a diferenciação funcional, a racionalização a societalização, a segurança existencial e a diversidade, igualitarismo e individualismo. Em segundo lugar, introduzimos aquela que, para o estado da arte, é a principal e mais desafiante alternativa às teorias da secularização -a economia religiosa -, examinando-a à luz dos seus pressupostos fundamentais. No final do trabalho, para efeitos de maior sistematização, oferecemos um quadro de análise com a comparação dos principais axiomas das duas teorias.Palavras-chave: teorias da secularização; camadas internas; teoria da economia religiosa; método comparativo Abstract Much has been written about secularization, but there have been few profound researches on its internal layers and on the most solid and systematic alternatives that followed. In our view, this has had two consequences: constraints of interpretative understanding and of analyticaltheoretical deepening that must and can be overcome. To achieve this goal, we have chosen a research design that encompasses the strategy of thick description as well as the comparative method and we divided the paper in two basic parts. First, we analyse the main substrates of secularization, namely functional differentiation, rationalization, societalization, existential security and diversity, egalitarianism and individualism. Secondly, we introduce the main and most challenging alternative to secularization theories, according to the state of the art -the religious economy -, examining it in the light of secularization's central assumptions. At the end of the paper, for a more systematic exam, we provide a table analysis comparing the main axioms of both theories.

show abstract

“…Il en va de même pour l'analyse des mécanismes sociaux de transformation des arrangements institutionnels. Celle-ci requiert l'analyse de la configuration des intérêts des acteurs religieux et politique (A. Gill, 2008) neo-institucionalismo, mundialización, racionalización, comparativismo. …”

unclassified

Multiple Modernities and Globalization

Koenig¹

2014

assr

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

The Political Origins of Religious Liberty

Cited by 112 publications

References 195 publications

Religious Freedom and the Idea of Establishing Islamic State

Religious Freedom and the Idea of Establishing Islamic State

Teorias da secularização e o modelo da economia religiosa

Multiple Modernities and Globalization

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About