The policy-practice gap: describing discordances between regulation on paper and real-life practices among specialized drug shops in Kenya

Abstract

BackgroundSpecialized drug shops (SDSs) are popular in Sub-Saharan Africa because they provide convenient access to medicines. There is increasing interest in how policymakers can work with them, but little knowledge on how their operation relates to regulatory frameworks. This study sought to describe characteristics and predictors of regulatory practices among SDSs in Kenya.MethodsThe regulatory framework governing the Kenya pharmaceutical sector was mapped, and a list of regulations selected for inclusion in a survey questionnaire. An SDS census was conducted, and survey data collected from 213 SDSs from two districts in Western Kenya.ResultsThe majority of SDSs did not comply with regulations, with only 12% having a refrigerator and 22% having a separate dispensing area for instance. Additionally, less than half had at least one staff with pharmacy qualification (46%), with less than a third of all interviewed operators knowing the name of the law governing pharmacy.Regulatory infringement was more common among SDSs in rural locations; those that did not have staff with pharmacy qualifications; and those whose operator did not know the name of the pharmacy law. Compliance was not significantly associated with the frequency of inspections, with over 80% of both rural and urban SDSs reporting an inspection in the past year.ConclusionWhile compliance was low overall, it was particularly poor among SDSs operating in rural locations, and those that did not have staff with pharmacy qualification. This suggested the need for policy to introduce levels of practice in recognition of the variations in resource availability. Under such a system, rural SDSs operating in low-resource setting, and selling a limited range of medicines, may be exempted from certain regulatory requirements, as long as their scope of practice is limited to certain essential services only. Future research should also explore why regulatory compliance is poor despite regular inspections.

Access to medicines for asthma, diabetes and hypertension in eight counties of Kenya

“…In general, medicines can account for 20–60% of healthcare spending and in many situations, up to 90% of the population purchase them through out‐of‐pocket payments . By law, prescription‐only medicines can only be dispensed with a valid prescription and sales need to be registered in a prescription recording book; however, in practice, retail pharmacies may not implement these requirements . The 2009 Access to Essential Medicines in Kenya report indicates that while medicines are generally affordable to the lowest wage government worker, the majority of Kenyans make less than this wage, indicating that medicines may not be affordable to many .…”

Healthcare clinic and pharmacy chains in Kenya and Nigeria: How are they regulated, and what opportunities and risks do they present to national regulatory systems?

“…Intense competition from chains could also encourage other providers to out regulations to gain a competitive advantage, in "race to the bottom" competition, where quality is compromised. Excessive retail-level competition has been linked to reduced regulatory compliance in Kenya (28). While there was no evidence of market dominance by chains as yet in either country, this may be a future risk, especially in prime business locations where chains are currently concentrated.…”

Compliance of private pharmacies in Uganda with controlled prescription drugs regulations: a mixed-methods study

“…Specifically, association of dispenser's age, years of dispensing experience and professional qualifications with noncompliance with prescription requirements for antibiotics have been reported [33,34]. A study on regulatory compliance of specialized drug shops in Kenya also found association between pharmacy qualifications and likelihood of regulatory compliance [35]. Meanwhile, findings from U.…”