The Policy Maker's Anguish: Regulating Personal Data Behavior Between Paradoxes and Dilemmas

Compañó, Ramón; Lusoli, Wainer

doi:10.1007/978-1-4419-6967-5_9

Cited by 32 publications

(29 citation statements)

References 5 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Alternatively, even when many online platforms give users the ability to maintain their preferred privacy settings [18], users do not always exercise this option in way that is consistent with their self-reported desires [33]. For instance, Facebook gives comprehensive privacy control to users, but users rarely take advantage of all of the privacy features available to them [4], [19]. Yet, researchers continue to attempt to alleviate users' privacy concerns by trying to give users more control over what data they wish to share, and by providing them with more information about the implications of their decisions [13], [15], [20]- [22].…”

Section: A Managing Networked Privacymentioning

confidence: 99%

(Work in Progress) User-Tailored Privacy by Design

Wilkinson¹,

Sivakumar²,

Cherry³

et al. 2017

Proceedings 2017 Workshop on Usable Security

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The "privacy by design" philosophy addresses privacy aspects early in the design and development of an information system. While privacy by design solutions often provide considerable advantages over "post hoc" privacy solutions, they are usually not customized to the needs of individual users. Further, research shows that users differ substantially in their privacy management strategies. Thus, how can we support such broad privacy needs in a comprehensive and user-centered way? This paper presents the idea of user-tailored privacy by design, a design methodology that combines multiple privacy features into a single intelligent user interface. We discuss how this methodology moves beyond the "one-size-fits-all" approach of existing privacy by design solutions and the narrow focus on information disclosure of existing user-tailored privacy solutions. We illustrate our approach through an implementation of usertailored privacy by design within Facebook based on six privacy management profiles that were discovered in recent work, and subsequently extend this idea to the context of the Total Learning Architecture (TLA), which is a next generation learning platform that uses pervasive user monitoring to provide highly adaptive learning recommendations.

show abstract

Section: A Managing Networked Privacymentioning

confidence: 99%

(Work in Progress) User-Tailored Privacy by Design

Wilkinson¹,

Sivakumar²,

Cherry³

et al. 2017

Proceedings 2017 Workshop on Usable Security

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Similarly, the ability to process presented information can be affected by personal characteristics (e.g., prior knowledge, expertise in subject matter) or situational factors (e.g., sufficient time, or lack of distraction) Petty et al, 1983). In privacy research, the idea that elaboration depends on motivation and ability is corroborated by privacy scholars who have argued that people use shortcuts and heuristics because they are incapable (Liu, Gummadi, Krishnamurthy, & Mislove, 2011;Madejski, Johnson, & Bellovin, 2012) or not motivated (Compañó & Lusoli, 2010) to perform an elaborate privacy calculus.…”

Section: Elaboration Likelihood Model For Privacy Decision Makingmentioning

confidence: 99%

The effect of personalization provider characteristics on privacy attitudes and behaviors: An Elaboration Likelihood Model approach

Kobsa

Cho

Knijnenburg

2016

Asso for Info Science & Tech

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Many computer users today value personalization but perceive it in conflict with their desire for privacy. They therefore tend not to disclose data that would be useful for personalization. We investigate how characteristics of the personalization provider influence users' attitudes towards personalization and their resulting disclosure behavior. We propose an integrative model that links these characteristics via privacy attitudes to actual disclosure behavior. Using the Elaboration Likelihood Model, we discuss in what way the influence of the manipulated provider characteristics is different for users engaging in different levels of elaboration (represented by the user characteristics of privacy concerns and self‐efficacy). We find particularly that (a) reputation management is effective when users predominantly use the peripheral route (i.e., a low level of elaboration), but much less so when they predominantly use the central route (i.e., a high level of elaboration); (b) client‐side personalization has a positive impact when users use either route; and (c) personalization in the cloud does not work well in either route. Managers and designers can use our results to instill more favorable privacy attitudes and increase disclosure, using different techniques that depend on each user's levels of privacy concerns and privacy self‐efficacy.

show abstract

“…Par ailleurs, peu d'individus protègent réellement leur vie privée, alors même que le coût (cognitif et financier) d'une telle protection, qu'elle soit de nature technique (logiciels anti-spam, anti-spyware, …), comportementale (limitation des données fournies) ou réglementaire (exercer son droit d'accès et de rectification) s'avère souvent limité. Ce deuxième écart, qualifié de paradoxe de contrôle ("control paradox") (Compano & Lusoli 2009), implique que des individus soucieux de contrôler leur vie privée, s'abstiennent pourtant de prendre des mesures visant à se protéger, alors même qu'ils sont conscients que de telles mesures existent et qu'elles peuvent être efficaces : J'avoue franchement que je squizze le truc marqué en tout petit, caractère 1, la loi Informatique et Liberté … généralement, je squizze. Sur les sites que je découvre moi-même, je fais plus attention, et encore.…”

Section: Les Paradoxes Liés Au Dévoilement Et à La Protection De La Vunclassified

Vie privée et marketing

Miltgen¹

2011

Réseaux

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Résumé Les TIC ont accru la possibilité de collecter et utiliser les données personnelles des citoyens. Si cela permet de concevoir des offres commerciales davantage personnalisées, l’utilisation parfois abusive de ces données pose problème. Cet article vise à comprendre la façon dont les internautes français perçoivent la sollicitation de leurs informations personnelles dans le cadre d’une relation commerciale avec un site. À travers neuf entretiens individuels, nous montrons que la décision de fournir des données à un organisme commercial serait plus liée au contexte dans laquelle la sollicitation s’opère qu’à une prédisposition à se dévoiler. Les dilemmes et paradoxes associés au dévoilement sont décrits et une justification à leur existence est proposée.

show abstract

The Policy Maker's Anguish: Regulating Personal Data Behavior Between Paradoxes and Dilemmas

Cited by 32 publications

References 5 publications

(Work in Progress) User-Tailored Privacy by Design

(Work in Progress) User-Tailored Privacy by Design

The effect of personalization provider characteristics on privacy attitudes and behaviors: An Elaboration Likelihood Model approach

Vie privée et marketing

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About