The phenomenology of chronic pain: embodiment and alienation

Abstract

This article develops a phenomenological exploration of chronic pain from a first-person perspective that can serve to enrich the medical third-person perspective. The experience of chronic pain is found to be a feeling in which we become alienated from the workings of our own bodies. The bodily-based mood of alienation is extended, however, in penetrating the whole world of the chronic pain sufferer, making her entire life unhomelike. Furthermore, the pain mood not only opens up the world as having an alien quality, it also makes the world more lonesome and poor by forcing the sufferer to attend to the workings of her own body. To suffer pain is to find oneself in a situation of passivity in relation to the hurtful experiences one is undergoing. In making the body and the world more unhomelike places to be in, pain also tends to rob a person of her language. Severe pain is hard to describe because it pushes the person towards the borderlines of imaginable experience and because it makes it hard to see any meaning and purpose in the situation one has been forced into. The analysis of chronic pain in the article is guided by the attempts made by Maurice Merleau-Ponty, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Martin Heidegger to understand the nature of human embodiment and existence, and also by descriptions of chronic pain found in the Swedish author Lars Gustafsson's novel The Death of a Beekeeper.

Facing a Disruptive Face: Embodiment in the Everyday Experiences of “Disfigured” Individuals

“…The body then dys-appears, in Leder's terms, and thereby interrupts the ill person's immersion in her lifeworld (1990: 83; 70 and 81). For Svenaeus (2000Svenaeus ( , 2009Svenaeus ( , 2015, the fact illness and disability disrupt the subject-body's implicit, habitual relation to her lifeworld, means that both body and world become uncanny: they lose their familiar, home-like quality.…”

Coping with chronic pain, illness and incarceration: what patients and prisoners have to teach each other (and all of us)

“…The world narrows down to the size of a room, a television screen, the objects available on the end-table. Those less incapacitated nonetheless dwell in a reduced world, one which feels ‘unhomelike’ 9. This is measured not so much through a physician’s metrics (‘on a scale of 1–10 how would you rate your pain today’) but through the extent to which pain and/or illness have restricted customary freedoms: to move up and down the stairs, join friends for lunch, work in the garden, or travel to one’s job.…”

Enabling at-homeness for residents living in a nursing home: Reflected experience of nursing home staff

“…The philosopher Svenaeus (2011) studied at-homeness philosophically in relation to illness as an unhomelike being-in-the-world experience, where illness could be understood as otherness, and where the person is not familiar with illness and is therefore experiencing themselves as an outsider in life (Svenaeus, 2011). Svenaeus further proposed that suffering chronic pain could make life as a whole unhomelike (Svenaeus, 2015). However, as described earlier, it is possible to experience at-homeness whilst having disease as is shown in a review by Öhlén et al, (2014); at-homeness in spite of illness lies on a continuum between the poles of at-homeness and homelesness where aspects of being safe, connected and centered were recognized.…”