The perceptions of general practitioners on National Health Insurance in Chris Hani district, Eastern Cape, South Africa

Abstract

Background: National Health Insurance (NHI) intends to provide universal health coverage to all South Africans, with equity and quality as its tenets. The participation of private general practitioners (GPs) in NHI is essential. The aim was to explore perceptions of GPs on NHI in Chris Hani district, Eastern Cape, South Africa. Methods: A descriptive phenomenological qualitative study using semi-structured individual interviews of 12 GPs from six municipalities was undertaken. Data analysis used the framework method assisted by Atlas.ti software. Results: GPs in Chris Hani district felt that NHI would improve health and benefit society and be of particular benefit to poor and rural people as it will improve access to healthcare. Lack of governmental administrative capacity and a human resource plan were seen as barriers to implementation. They believed that NHI would benefit them through a single purchaser system and support more comprehensive care. GPs were concerned about a lack of information on primary care packages, accreditation, remuneration and patient allocation. They thought that NHI might disadvantage solo GPs. NHI implementation could be improved by actively engaging with GP organisations. Improvement of existing government health facilities and continued medical education were seen as possible ways to better implement NHI. Conclusion GPs in this study were generally positive about NHI and thought it would benefit both patients and providers. However, they had concerns regarding the capacity of government to implement NHI and the implications for solo GPs, and needed more information. Government needs to actively engage GPs.

Exploring the beliefs and attitudes of private general practitioners towards national health insurance in Cape Town, South Africa

“…Detailed exploration and piloting of provider payment methods by the NHI task team at the National Department of Health is needed to find options that will encourage GPs to participate in the NHI. Future research may be able to quantify the issues explored in this and other studies 23,25 through a national descriptive survey of GPs.…”

Policy developer’s perceptions on the implementation of National Health Insurance in South Africa: a qualitative study

“…The current system is constructed of two tiers, i.e., the private sector and public sector. The majority of financial and human resources lie within the private sector which services ~ 16% of the population, whereas the public sector services ~ 84% of the population [ 3 , 4 ]. The country’s healthcare profile faces a quadruple burden of disease, resulting in significant strain on the public healthcare sector.…”

Mistrust in government and National Health Insurance: A qualitative study of solo private practitioners in Cape Town

“…In his study in the Western Cape, Valley 12 highlighted poor communication between the provincial health department and the private GPs as a primary concern. In a recent study of GP perceptions towards NHI in the Chris Hani District, Gaqavu and Mash 13 reported GP uncertainty around the government’s capacity to implement the policy and implications for solo GPs. The GPs also voiced a need for more information and engagement by government.…”