The pedagogical logics of arts-rich schools: a Bourdieusian analysis

Abstract

The arts are under threat in English schools. But some schools and teachers work against the trend. To understand how they continue to offer rich arts experiences to students, we bring Bourdieusian thinking to arts teacher practices that were common across the thirty secondary schools we studied for three years. In addition to a flexible approach to the curriculum which encouraged independence, intellectual challenge and risk -taking, teachers also engaged in arts brokerageembodiment of arts engagement, ensuring students regularly visit cultural events/ institutions, using local cultural resources, organising visits from artists/cultural organisations, enabling students to exhibit and perform for wider audiences, connecting students with arts workplaces, and enhancing community arts participation. We approach this as a logic of practice associated with arts broker dis/positions drawn from teachers simultaneously occupying two chiasmatic fields -art and education.

‘The shape of things that are and were’ and ‘the shape of things to come’: some reflections on the sociology of education at the 40th anniversary of BJSE

“…Bourdieu and Passeron 1979). Indeed, even from within Bourdieu's own conceptual framework, "change in a field is not only possible but inevitable" and "even though fields are reproductive, they are not uniform" (Thomson et al 2019). As Gramsci (1973)…”

‘Becoming more confident in being themselves’: The value of cultural and creative engagement for young people in foster care – Dawn Mannay, Phil Smith, Catt Turney, Stephen Jennings and Peter Davies

“…The flexibility of the arts programme meant that the facilitators could avoid the re-creation of ‘schooled subjects’ and ‘schooled docility’ (Gallacher and Gallagher, 2008: 506) and they reported that developing supportive non-hierarchical relationships and emotional connections within the group helped the young people to feel secure. As in Thomson et al.’s (2019: 247) study with teachers, the facilitators could also be positioned as ‘arts brokers’, as they ‘embodied what it means to be culturally engaged’ and situated creativity as integral to everyday life, actively communicating this centrality to young people.…”

‘You just feel more relaxed’: An Investigation of Art Room Atmosphere

“…Some art teachers also see that art practice means wider social and political questioning and engagement. These 'arts broker' teachers bring their own cultural participation and engagement to their work, demonstrating what it means for art practice to be an integral part of everyday life (Thomson et al 2019a). However, it is the commitment to the potential for everyone to have an idea, and realise it, that provides the moral foundation for the organisational and epistemological/methodological basis of the signature pedagogy creative project and contributes to the aesthetics and relationalities of art room atmosphere.…”