The paucity of morality in everyday talk

Abstract

Given its centrality in scholarly and popular discourse, morality should be expected to figure prominently in everyday talk. We test this expectation by examining the frequency of moral content in three contexts, using three methods: (a) Participants’ subjective frequency estimates (N = 581); (b) Human content analysis of unobtrusively recorded in-person interactions (N = 542 participants; n = 50,961 observations); and (c) Computational content analysis of Facebook posts (N = 3822 participants; n = 111,886 observations). In their self-reports, participants estimated that 21.5% of their interactions touched on morality (Study 1), but objectively, only 4.7% of recorded conversational samples (Study 2) and 2.2% of Facebook posts (Study 3) contained moral content. Collectively, these findings suggest that morality may be far less prominent in everyday life than scholarly and popular discourse, and laypeople, presume.

Morality in the anthropocene: The perversion of compassion and punishment in the online world

“…2 ). This is a striking difference from the infrequency of morality in everyday conversations ( 44 ) and underscores the centrality of morality online. We describe two factors that exploit people's attention towards morality in the online environment: overabundance and extremity.…”

Expressing and developing wisdom: A self-determination theory approach.

“…Morality features prominently in everyday life (Hofmann et al, 2014; cf., Atari et al, 2023) and, thus, may often become the subject of metacognitive processes. In the Common Wisdom Model, moral grounding of metacognitive processes is the second common denominator in empirical approaches to the study of wisdom.…”

Verbal behavior and the future of social science.

“…Despite the popular notion that verbal behavior is somehow unique or special, it can be viewed as merely one color in the kaleidoscope of human behavior. Verbal behavior is learned via the same processes as other behaviors-such as reinforcement learning and successive approximation (Bandura, 1977;Goddard, 2018)-and, like other behaviors, does not possess a one-to-one correspondence with psychological states or traits (Atari et al, 2023;Searle, 1970). Just as a wave of the hand may be an enthusiastic greeting to a friend or a frantic attempt to 4 While most computational social science scholars who use NLP may not state this assumption in their work, or even be explicitly aware of its presence, the roots of their research can nearly always be found in the "words-as-attention" framework.…”