bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus). We find that LHT is important for determining the 37 vulnerability of fish populations to overfishing, with pike, pikeperch, and bull trout being 38 more vulnerable than perch and brown trout. Angler type influences the magnitude of fishing 39 impacts, due to differences in fishing practices and angler-type-specific effects of LHT on 40 angling effort. Our results indicate that angler types are systematically attracted to particular 41LHTs. Socially optimal minimum-size limits generally increase with LHT vulnerability, 42 whereas optimal license densities are similar across LHTs. Yet, both regulations vary among 43 angler types. Despite this variation, we find that biological sustainability occurs under 44 socially optimal regulations, with one exception. Our results highlight the importance of 45 jointly considering fish diversity, angler diversity, and regulations when predicting 46 sustainable management strategies for recreational fisheries. Failure to do so could result in 47 socially suboptimal management, fishery collapse, or both.