The Origins of Violence in Rwanda

Abstract

<jats:title>Abstract</jats:title> <jats:p>This article shows that the intensity of violence in Rwanda’s recent past can be traced back to the initial establishment of its pre-colonial state. Villages that were brought under centralized rule one century earlier experienced a doubling of violence during the state-organized 1994 genocide. Instrumental variable estimates exploiting differences in the proximity to Nyanza—an early capital—suggest that these effects are causal. Before the genocide, when the state faced rebel attacks, with longer state presence, violence is lower. Using data from several sources, including a lab-in-the-field experiment across an abandoned historical boundary, I show that the effect of the historical state is primarily sustained by culturally transmitted norms of obedience. The persistent effect of the pre-colonial state interacts with government policy: where the state developed earlier, there is more violence when the Rwandan government mobilized for mass killing and less violence when the government pursued peace.</jats:p>

On the Economic Origins of Restrictions on Women's Sexuality

“…Ashraf et al, 2010;Beaman et al, 2009;Field et al, 2010), and, more broadly, to the literature on the role of culture in understanding economically relevant phenomena (Fernandez and Fogli, 2009;Giuliano, 2007;Guiso et al, 2006Guiso et al, , 2008. It also speaks to the recent literature on the effect of historical experiences on variation in norms (Heldring, 2018), trust (Chen and Yang, 2016;Nunn and Wantchekon, 2011;Lowes and Montero, 2018), antiimmigrant sentiments (Tabellini, forthcoming), individualism (Bazzi et al, 2018), or prevalence of democratic institutions (Schulz, 2017).…”

The Golden City on the Edge: Economic Geography and Jihad over Centuries

“…First, this paper contributes to the literature on the economics of conflicts, being closely connected to research on the historical origins of contemporary conflicts (Arbatlı et al 2020;Boxell et al 2019;Besley and Reynal-Querol 2014;Depetris-Chauvin 2015;Depetris-Chauvin and Özak 2020;Heldring 2021;Jha 2013;Michalopoulos and Papaioannou 2016;Moscona et al 2020). In particular, Depetris-Chauvin (2015) and Heldring (2021), which examine the relationship between historical states and contemporary conflicts, are most relevant to our work. 3 These papers focus on the historical presences of state-like institutions and look at the persistence of these institutions.…”

Persecution, Pogroms and Genocide: A Conceptual Framework and New Evidence

“…There is relatively little work on the long-run determinants of persecution and genocide outside the context of the persecution of Jews. Heldring (2021) shows that the intensity of violence in Rwanda's recent past can be traced back to the initial establishment of its pre-colonial state. Areas with a longer history of a centralized state are more easily activated by the Rwandan government, for good or bad, as these areas have a more deeply rooted culture of obedience to authority.…”