The Origins of Modern Nationalism in the North Atlantic Interaction Sphere

Abstract

This article challenges the standard narrative (e.g. Gellner) regarding the origins of modern nationalism in Europe, and Benedict Anderson's contrary suggestion that it first took shape in creole America, arguing instead that the formation of modern nationalism needs to be understood as a transatlantic process, in keeping with recent research on Atlantic history. More specifically, the North Atlantic dynamic of imperial competition between Britain and France, that led to the American and French Revolutions, is seen as the crucible of modern state formation, and it is argued that the North Atlantic needs to be understood not simply as a geographic space, but as a distinctive sphere of social and ideological interaction, given the centrality of sea-going during this period. It was this complex social environment, centred on a long18th century, that most provoked new imaginings of national community. Toward this end the article articulates the analytic concept of the ‘interaction sphere’. With this it picks up on Charles Tilly's key concerns with how best to analyse large historical processes, and his emphasis on political competition and social interaction in explaining social change.

The Nation as Propertied Community: The Emergence of Nationalism in the United States and Norway

“…In fact, the national revolutions of the United States and Norway mark the beginning and the end of a series of nationalist revolutions in the western hemisphere. The U.S. and Norway were part of what Jonathan Hearn has called ‘the North Atlantic Interaction Sphere’ (Hearn ). Starting with the American Revolution, expressions of nationalism in the form of liberation movements promoting liberal constitutions emerged in a spatial sphere covering North America and Western Europe, as well as large parts of Latin America in the years between 1776 and 1814.…”

Seventh nations and nationalism debate: Joep Leerssen's National Thought in Europe: A Cultural History

“…I think the relevant universe of ideas and ideological interactions feeding into the idea of nations spanned the Atlantic, and involved non‐European others, including indigenous peoples, slaves and even such odd interstitial societies as pirates. I question whether Europe is indeed the complete heartland of nationalism (Hearn , see also Kramer ).…”

Nationalism and Globalization: Challenging Assumptions

“…8 With European colonization of the Americas and the growth of transatlantic trade networks, a new worldview evolved as European empires became overstretched and unable to maintain systems of rule. A transatlantic milieu of intellectuals, especially in the British American colonies and France, elaborated new ideas of democracy, republicanism, and collective self-rule that came to the forefront in the respective revolutions of 1776 and 1789.…”